Should my fighter really punch that werewolf?











up vote
45
down vote

favorite
5












A werewolf from the MM has the following in its stat block:




Damage Immunities: Bludgeoning, Piercing, And Slashing Damage From Nonmagical Weapons That Aren't Silvered




And as established in the errata, unarmed strikes aren't weapons.




Weapons (p. 149). Unarmed strike doesn’t belong on the Weapons table.




and




Melee Attacks (p. 195). The rule on
unarmed strikes should read as follows:
“Instead of using a weapon to make a
melee weapon attack, you can use an unarmed
strike: a punch, kick, head-butt, or
similar forceful blow (none of which count
as weapons). On a hit, an unarmed strike
deals bludgeoning damage equal to 1 +
your Strength modifier. You are proficient
with your unarmed strikes.”




And confirmed by Jeremy Crawford




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon attacks use unarmed strikes, despite those strikes not being weapons.




Does this mean my fighter, who doesn't have a magical or silvered weapon can, instead, punch a werewolf in the face for 4 damage?










share|improve this question
























  • Related: rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/97419/…
    – Tim Grant
    Nov 13 at 23:37










  • Silver "Star" Stallone can punch a were-creature for Rocky damages.
    – Cœur
    2 days ago















up vote
45
down vote

favorite
5












A werewolf from the MM has the following in its stat block:




Damage Immunities: Bludgeoning, Piercing, And Slashing Damage From Nonmagical Weapons That Aren't Silvered




And as established in the errata, unarmed strikes aren't weapons.




Weapons (p. 149). Unarmed strike doesn’t belong on the Weapons table.




and




Melee Attacks (p. 195). The rule on
unarmed strikes should read as follows:
“Instead of using a weapon to make a
melee weapon attack, you can use an unarmed
strike: a punch, kick, head-butt, or
similar forceful blow (none of which count
as weapons). On a hit, an unarmed strike
deals bludgeoning damage equal to 1 +
your Strength modifier. You are proficient
with your unarmed strikes.”




And confirmed by Jeremy Crawford




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon attacks use unarmed strikes, despite those strikes not being weapons.




Does this mean my fighter, who doesn't have a magical or silvered weapon can, instead, punch a werewolf in the face for 4 damage?










share|improve this question
























  • Related: rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/97419/…
    – Tim Grant
    Nov 13 at 23:37










  • Silver "Star" Stallone can punch a were-creature for Rocky damages.
    – Cœur
    2 days ago













up vote
45
down vote

favorite
5









up vote
45
down vote

favorite
5






5





A werewolf from the MM has the following in its stat block:




Damage Immunities: Bludgeoning, Piercing, And Slashing Damage From Nonmagical Weapons That Aren't Silvered




And as established in the errata, unarmed strikes aren't weapons.




Weapons (p. 149). Unarmed strike doesn’t belong on the Weapons table.




and




Melee Attacks (p. 195). The rule on
unarmed strikes should read as follows:
“Instead of using a weapon to make a
melee weapon attack, you can use an unarmed
strike: a punch, kick, head-butt, or
similar forceful blow (none of which count
as weapons). On a hit, an unarmed strike
deals bludgeoning damage equal to 1 +
your Strength modifier. You are proficient
with your unarmed strikes.”




And confirmed by Jeremy Crawford




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon attacks use unarmed strikes, despite those strikes not being weapons.




Does this mean my fighter, who doesn't have a magical or silvered weapon can, instead, punch a werewolf in the face for 4 damage?










share|improve this question















A werewolf from the MM has the following in its stat block:




Damage Immunities: Bludgeoning, Piercing, And Slashing Damage From Nonmagical Weapons That Aren't Silvered




And as established in the errata, unarmed strikes aren't weapons.




Weapons (p. 149). Unarmed strike doesn’t belong on the Weapons table.




and




Melee Attacks (p. 195). The rule on
unarmed strikes should read as follows:
“Instead of using a weapon to make a
melee weapon attack, you can use an unarmed
strike: a punch, kick, head-butt, or
similar forceful blow (none of which count
as weapons). On a hit, an unarmed strike
deals bludgeoning damage equal to 1 +
your Strength modifier. You are proficient
with your unarmed strikes.”




And confirmed by Jeremy Crawford




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon attacks use unarmed strikes, despite those strikes not being weapons.




Does this mean my fighter, who doesn't have a magical or silvered weapon can, instead, punch a werewolf in the face for 4 damage?







dnd-5e rules-as-written monsters unarmed-combat immunities






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Nov 13 at 16:23









doppelgreener

31.8k11136226




31.8k11136226










asked Nov 13 at 16:11









Matt Rick

832515




832515












  • Related: rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/97419/…
    – Tim Grant
    Nov 13 at 23:37










  • Silver "Star" Stallone can punch a were-creature for Rocky damages.
    – Cœur
    2 days ago


















  • Related: rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/97419/…
    – Tim Grant
    Nov 13 at 23:37










  • Silver "Star" Stallone can punch a were-creature for Rocky damages.
    – Cœur
    2 days ago
















Related: rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/97419/…
– Tim Grant
Nov 13 at 23:37




Related: rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/97419/…
– Tim Grant
Nov 13 at 23:37












Silver "Star" Stallone can punch a were-creature for Rocky damages.
– Cœur
2 days ago




Silver "Star" Stallone can punch a were-creature for Rocky damages.
– Cœur
2 days ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
66
down vote



accepted










This does not work.



Your quote is outdated.



The Monster Manual Errata shows that you no longer should reference weapons. Meaning it doesn't matter what you attack with so long as that attack, not weapon, meets the criteria in the entry.



In this case you can make an attack with your unarmed strike that doesn't count as a weapon, but the fact that it is not considered a weapon is made irrelevant.




Damage Resistances/Immunities. Throughout the book, instances of “nonmagical weapons” in Damage Resistances/Immunities entries have been replaced with “nonmagical attacks.”




So the "corrected" entry would read as follows:




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical Attacks that aren't Silvered




This is in fact what the errataed werewolf entry on D&D Beyond now says.






share|improve this answer



















  • 6




    Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
    – Matt Rick
    Nov 13 at 16:26






  • 7




    @MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 16:28






  • 3




    What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
    – Tezra
    Nov 13 at 17:32






  • 4




    @Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 18:00






  • 5




    @user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 19:36


















up vote
16
down vote













Unless your PC is a level 6+ monk, fists aren't magical attacks



And your characters hands aren't silver. Thus, the attacks are non-silvered, and non-magical, per the MM requirement on how to damage a werewolf.




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical
Attacks that aren't Silvered




What might work is ... wearing silver rings on the fighter's fingers



The "silvering" of a weapon is left a little vague, albeit it is expensive for a low level character.




You can silver a single weapon or ten pieces of ammunition for 100 gp.
This cost represents not only the price of the silver, but the time
and expertise needed to add silver to the weapon without making it
less effective. (Basic Rules, p. 47)




What is "silvering" at your table? How does it work? Discuss this with your DM.



With that in mind, and with Crawfords SA input considered...




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon
attacks use unarmed strikes
, despite those strikes not being weapons.




... wearing silver rings on your fingers might count as "silvered" for purposes of attacking a lycanthrope with a fist/punch. Work with your DM; it seems a reasonable approach for "silvering" the attacks with your character's hands.



Aside: I've read any number of short stories where were-creatures are foiled by silver rings, silver guitar strings, silver amulets ... but that's a literary reference, not a D&D 5e rules reference.






share|improve this answer



















  • 2




    Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
    – V2Blast
    Nov 13 at 20:56








  • 2




    @V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
    – Geoffrey Brent
    Nov 13 at 22:30










  • @GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
    – KorvinStarmast
    Nov 13 at 23:03










  • The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
    – Robotnik
    2 days ago












  • @Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
    – Perkins
    2 days ago













Your Answer





StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");

StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "122"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});


}
});














 

draft saved


draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f135465%2fshould-my-fighter-really-punch-that-werewolf%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes








2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes








up vote
66
down vote



accepted










This does not work.



Your quote is outdated.



The Monster Manual Errata shows that you no longer should reference weapons. Meaning it doesn't matter what you attack with so long as that attack, not weapon, meets the criteria in the entry.



In this case you can make an attack with your unarmed strike that doesn't count as a weapon, but the fact that it is not considered a weapon is made irrelevant.




Damage Resistances/Immunities. Throughout the book, instances of “nonmagical weapons” in Damage Resistances/Immunities entries have been replaced with “nonmagical attacks.”




So the "corrected" entry would read as follows:




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical Attacks that aren't Silvered




This is in fact what the errataed werewolf entry on D&D Beyond now says.






share|improve this answer



















  • 6




    Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
    – Matt Rick
    Nov 13 at 16:26






  • 7




    @MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 16:28






  • 3




    What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
    – Tezra
    Nov 13 at 17:32






  • 4




    @Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 18:00






  • 5




    @user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 19:36















up vote
66
down vote



accepted










This does not work.



Your quote is outdated.



The Monster Manual Errata shows that you no longer should reference weapons. Meaning it doesn't matter what you attack with so long as that attack, not weapon, meets the criteria in the entry.



In this case you can make an attack with your unarmed strike that doesn't count as a weapon, but the fact that it is not considered a weapon is made irrelevant.




Damage Resistances/Immunities. Throughout the book, instances of “nonmagical weapons” in Damage Resistances/Immunities entries have been replaced with “nonmagical attacks.”




So the "corrected" entry would read as follows:




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical Attacks that aren't Silvered




This is in fact what the errataed werewolf entry on D&D Beyond now says.






share|improve this answer



















  • 6




    Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
    – Matt Rick
    Nov 13 at 16:26






  • 7




    @MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 16:28






  • 3




    What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
    – Tezra
    Nov 13 at 17:32






  • 4




    @Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 18:00






  • 5




    @user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 19:36













up vote
66
down vote



accepted







up vote
66
down vote



accepted






This does not work.



Your quote is outdated.



The Monster Manual Errata shows that you no longer should reference weapons. Meaning it doesn't matter what you attack with so long as that attack, not weapon, meets the criteria in the entry.



In this case you can make an attack with your unarmed strike that doesn't count as a weapon, but the fact that it is not considered a weapon is made irrelevant.




Damage Resistances/Immunities. Throughout the book, instances of “nonmagical weapons” in Damage Resistances/Immunities entries have been replaced with “nonmagical attacks.”




So the "corrected" entry would read as follows:




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical Attacks that aren't Silvered




This is in fact what the errataed werewolf entry on D&D Beyond now says.






share|improve this answer














This does not work.



Your quote is outdated.



The Monster Manual Errata shows that you no longer should reference weapons. Meaning it doesn't matter what you attack with so long as that attack, not weapon, meets the criteria in the entry.



In this case you can make an attack with your unarmed strike that doesn't count as a weapon, but the fact that it is not considered a weapon is made irrelevant.




Damage Resistances/Immunities. Throughout the book, instances of “nonmagical weapons” in Damage Resistances/Immunities entries have been replaced with “nonmagical attacks.”




So the "corrected" entry would read as follows:




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical Attacks that aren't Silvered




This is in fact what the errataed werewolf entry on D&D Beyond now says.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited Nov 13 at 16:28









Carcer

20.5k255112




20.5k255112










answered Nov 13 at 16:23









Slagmoth

16.6k14691




16.6k14691








  • 6




    Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
    – Matt Rick
    Nov 13 at 16:26






  • 7




    @MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 16:28






  • 3




    What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
    – Tezra
    Nov 13 at 17:32






  • 4




    @Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 18:00






  • 5




    @user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 19:36














  • 6




    Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
    – Matt Rick
    Nov 13 at 16:26






  • 7




    @MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 16:28






  • 3




    What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
    – Tezra
    Nov 13 at 17:32






  • 4




    @Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 18:00






  • 5




    @user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
    – Slagmoth
    Nov 13 at 19:36








6




6




Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
– Matt Rick
Nov 13 at 16:26




Disappointing, but, honestly, the only sensible outcome.
– Matt Rick
Nov 13 at 16:26




7




7




@MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
– Slagmoth
Nov 13 at 16:28




@MattRick Not sure... the fighter can still punch the werewolf... it makes a good scene, that the fighter does so out of ignorance or desperation. Mechanically it doesn't work but thematically and for the sake of a story it is a good fit.
– Slagmoth
Nov 13 at 16:28




3




3




What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
– Tezra
Nov 13 at 17:32




What if the fighter is wearing a silver ring? Would that work?
– Tezra
Nov 13 at 17:32




4




4




@Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
– Slagmoth
Nov 13 at 18:00




@Tezra That is a tricky question and would depend on your DM. On the one hand if you used a silver goblet as an improvized weapon I think the rules as well as the intent would support that but for some DMs it would be a hard sell to state that a ring on your finger would be considered an improvised weapon.
– Slagmoth
Nov 13 at 18:00




5




5




@user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
– Slagmoth
Nov 13 at 19:36




@user45114 Or like Mr. T and have a bunch of rings that would pretty much amount to a large set of brass/silver knuckles. At which point I would probably consider it a weapon, similar to a cestus. But for realism, you wouldn't have the same support and could have some damage yourself localized to your hands... but like I said, table mileage on that will vary as not all DMs will agree.
– Slagmoth
Nov 13 at 19:36












up vote
16
down vote













Unless your PC is a level 6+ monk, fists aren't magical attacks



And your characters hands aren't silver. Thus, the attacks are non-silvered, and non-magical, per the MM requirement on how to damage a werewolf.




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical
Attacks that aren't Silvered




What might work is ... wearing silver rings on the fighter's fingers



The "silvering" of a weapon is left a little vague, albeit it is expensive for a low level character.




You can silver a single weapon or ten pieces of ammunition for 100 gp.
This cost represents not only the price of the silver, but the time
and expertise needed to add silver to the weapon without making it
less effective. (Basic Rules, p. 47)




What is "silvering" at your table? How does it work? Discuss this with your DM.



With that in mind, and with Crawfords SA input considered...




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon
attacks use unarmed strikes
, despite those strikes not being weapons.




... wearing silver rings on your fingers might count as "silvered" for purposes of attacking a lycanthrope with a fist/punch. Work with your DM; it seems a reasonable approach for "silvering" the attacks with your character's hands.



Aside: I've read any number of short stories where were-creatures are foiled by silver rings, silver guitar strings, silver amulets ... but that's a literary reference, not a D&D 5e rules reference.






share|improve this answer



















  • 2




    Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
    – V2Blast
    Nov 13 at 20:56








  • 2




    @V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
    – Geoffrey Brent
    Nov 13 at 22:30










  • @GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
    – KorvinStarmast
    Nov 13 at 23:03










  • The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
    – Robotnik
    2 days ago












  • @Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
    – Perkins
    2 days ago

















up vote
16
down vote













Unless your PC is a level 6+ monk, fists aren't magical attacks



And your characters hands aren't silver. Thus, the attacks are non-silvered, and non-magical, per the MM requirement on how to damage a werewolf.




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical
Attacks that aren't Silvered




What might work is ... wearing silver rings on the fighter's fingers



The "silvering" of a weapon is left a little vague, albeit it is expensive for a low level character.




You can silver a single weapon or ten pieces of ammunition for 100 gp.
This cost represents not only the price of the silver, but the time
and expertise needed to add silver to the weapon without making it
less effective. (Basic Rules, p. 47)




What is "silvering" at your table? How does it work? Discuss this with your DM.



With that in mind, and with Crawfords SA input considered...




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon
attacks use unarmed strikes
, despite those strikes not being weapons.




... wearing silver rings on your fingers might count as "silvered" for purposes of attacking a lycanthrope with a fist/punch. Work with your DM; it seems a reasonable approach for "silvering" the attacks with your character's hands.



Aside: I've read any number of short stories where were-creatures are foiled by silver rings, silver guitar strings, silver amulets ... but that's a literary reference, not a D&D 5e rules reference.






share|improve this answer



















  • 2




    Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
    – V2Blast
    Nov 13 at 20:56








  • 2




    @V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
    – Geoffrey Brent
    Nov 13 at 22:30










  • @GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
    – KorvinStarmast
    Nov 13 at 23:03










  • The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
    – Robotnik
    2 days ago












  • @Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
    – Perkins
    2 days ago















up vote
16
down vote










up vote
16
down vote









Unless your PC is a level 6+ monk, fists aren't magical attacks



And your characters hands aren't silver. Thus, the attacks are non-silvered, and non-magical, per the MM requirement on how to damage a werewolf.




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical
Attacks that aren't Silvered




What might work is ... wearing silver rings on the fighter's fingers



The "silvering" of a weapon is left a little vague, albeit it is expensive for a low level character.




You can silver a single weapon or ten pieces of ammunition for 100 gp.
This cost represents not only the price of the silver, but the time
and expertise needed to add silver to the weapon without making it
less effective. (Basic Rules, p. 47)




What is "silvering" at your table? How does it work? Discuss this with your DM.



With that in mind, and with Crawfords SA input considered...




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon
attacks use unarmed strikes
, despite those strikes not being weapons.




... wearing silver rings on your fingers might count as "silvered" for purposes of attacking a lycanthrope with a fist/punch. Work with your DM; it seems a reasonable approach for "silvering" the attacks with your character's hands.



Aside: I've read any number of short stories where were-creatures are foiled by silver rings, silver guitar strings, silver amulets ... but that's a literary reference, not a D&D 5e rules reference.






share|improve this answer














Unless your PC is a level 6+ monk, fists aren't magical attacks



And your characters hands aren't silver. Thus, the attacks are non-silvered, and non-magical, per the MM requirement on how to damage a werewolf.




Damage Immunities Bludgeoning, Piercing, and Slashing from Nonmagical
Attacks that aren't Silvered




What might work is ... wearing silver rings on the fighter's fingers



The "silvering" of a weapon is left a little vague, albeit it is expensive for a low level character.




You can silver a single weapon or ten pieces of ammunition for 100 gp.
This cost represents not only the price of the silver, but the time
and expertise needed to add silver to the weapon without making it
less effective. (Basic Rules, p. 47)




What is "silvering" at your table? How does it work? Discuss this with your DM.



With that in mind, and with Crawfords SA input considered...




Addressing a nuance in the PH errata: the rule lets melee weapon
attacks use unarmed strikes
, despite those strikes not being weapons.




... wearing silver rings on your fingers might count as "silvered" for purposes of attacking a lycanthrope with a fist/punch. Work with your DM; it seems a reasonable approach for "silvering" the attacks with your character's hands.



Aside: I've read any number of short stories where were-creatures are foiled by silver rings, silver guitar strings, silver amulets ... but that's a literary reference, not a D&D 5e rules reference.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited Nov 13 at 16:59

























answered Nov 13 at 16:31









KorvinStarmast

70.8k17222390




70.8k17222390








  • 2




    Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
    – V2Blast
    Nov 13 at 20:56








  • 2




    @V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
    – Geoffrey Brent
    Nov 13 at 22:30










  • @GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
    – KorvinStarmast
    Nov 13 at 23:03










  • The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
    – Robotnik
    2 days ago












  • @Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
    – Perkins
    2 days ago
















  • 2




    Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
    – V2Blast
    Nov 13 at 20:56








  • 2




    @V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
    – Geoffrey Brent
    Nov 13 at 22:30










  • @GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
    – KorvinStarmast
    Nov 13 at 23:03










  • The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
    – Robotnik
    2 days ago












  • @Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
    – Perkins
    2 days ago










2




2




Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
– V2Blast
Nov 13 at 20:56






Crawford's response to the idea of actually silvering your fist: "From PH errata: An unarmed strike is a nonweapon [you can't silver a fist] that can make a melee weapon attack. [...] Please report to an ER immediately if you have tried to silver your fist." :P
– V2Blast
Nov 13 at 20:56






2




2




@V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
– Geoffrey Brent
Nov 13 at 22:30




@V2Blast well, you can silver your fist, if you're willing to silver everything else at the same time... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argyria
– Geoffrey Brent
Nov 13 at 22:30












@GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
– KorvinStarmast
Nov 13 at 23:03




@GeoffreyBrent There was an Eddie Murphy line in a movie about having part of his body bronzed (in 48 hours) that is a funny variation on your comment, but not a good fit for this question and answer.
– KorvinStarmast
Nov 13 at 23:03












The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
– Robotnik
2 days ago






The question OP, with input from their DM could homebrew up a gauntlet or a set of brass knuckles. Silvering the knuckles and using the "Uses your unarmed damage" variation would be a good compromise solution
– Robotnik
2 days ago














@Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
– Perkins
2 days ago






@Robotnik depending on why silvered blunt weapons actually manage to damage a werewolf when non-silver ones don't, potentially a roll of silver coins in your fist might be sufficient. Which could prove entertaining.
– Perkins
2 days ago




















 

draft saved


draft discarded



















































 


draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f135465%2fshould-my-fighter-really-punch-that-werewolf%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

Ellipse (mathématiques)

Quarter-circle Tiles

Mont Emei