Does MTG have a card with a mana-generating ability that has a target and is thus not a mana ability?
up vote
17
down vote
favorite
Just out of curiosity: The rules say:
605.1a An activated ability is a mana ability if it meets all of the following criteria: it doesn’t have a target, it could add mana to a player’s mana pool when it resolves, and it’s not a loyalty ability. (See rule 606, “Loyalty Abilities.”)
So, are there currently abilities on cards that do have a target, but could add mana on resolve and are no loyalty abilities, thus using the stack?
I'm asking because until recently I falsely believed that all abilities that generate mana are mana abilities and are thus exceptions to the "abilities go to the stack" rule. But it wouldn't be MTG if rules didn't have exceptions to exceptions, so it'd be good to know which cards to look out for. Even if some of them are joke cards like Unglued it'd be nice to know them just for the sake of knowing.
magic-the-gathering
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
add a comment |
up vote
17
down vote
favorite
Just out of curiosity: The rules say:
605.1a An activated ability is a mana ability if it meets all of the following criteria: it doesn’t have a target, it could add mana to a player’s mana pool when it resolves, and it’s not a loyalty ability. (See rule 606, “Loyalty Abilities.”)
So, are there currently abilities on cards that do have a target, but could add mana on resolve and are no loyalty abilities, thus using the stack?
I'm asking because until recently I falsely believed that all abilities that generate mana are mana abilities and are thus exceptions to the "abilities go to the stack" rule. But it wouldn't be MTG if rules didn't have exceptions to exceptions, so it'd be good to know which cards to look out for. Even if some of them are joke cards like Unglued it'd be nice to know them just for the sake of knowing.
magic-the-gathering
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
The answers provide examples of things that are not mana abilities. One thing to note is that, as long as it doesn't target, it is a mana ability no matter how complicated. See Selvala, Explorer Returned for an example of something truly absurd that is still a mana ability and does not use the stack.
– Zags
Nov 14 at 22:07
In case you are wondering about triggered abilities instead of activated abilities: Vernal Bloom is an example of a triggered mana ability while Eladamri’s Vineyard generates mana while not being a mana ability. see rule 605.1b
– Ivo Beckers
Nov 15 at 13:33
While I am also interested in triggered abilities, I don't see why Eladamri’s Vineyard is no mana ability, because "each player" means that it's not targeted either.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 13:51
1
605.1b specifies that a triggered ability is only a mana ability if it either comes from the resolution of an activated mana ability or from mana being added to a mana pool. That's why Eladamri's Vineyard is not a mana ability. As far why they chose it to be this way, I don't know.
– Manuel Hoffmann
Nov 15 at 15:24
Oh. My god! O_O That is very good to know, because I like to play Mana Echoes, whose ability, as it turns out, is not a mana ability, either, then.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 15:37
add a comment |
up vote
17
down vote
favorite
up vote
17
down vote
favorite
Just out of curiosity: The rules say:
605.1a An activated ability is a mana ability if it meets all of the following criteria: it doesn’t have a target, it could add mana to a player’s mana pool when it resolves, and it’s not a loyalty ability. (See rule 606, “Loyalty Abilities.”)
So, are there currently abilities on cards that do have a target, but could add mana on resolve and are no loyalty abilities, thus using the stack?
I'm asking because until recently I falsely believed that all abilities that generate mana are mana abilities and are thus exceptions to the "abilities go to the stack" rule. But it wouldn't be MTG if rules didn't have exceptions to exceptions, so it'd be good to know which cards to look out for. Even if some of them are joke cards like Unglued it'd be nice to know them just for the sake of knowing.
magic-the-gathering
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
Just out of curiosity: The rules say:
605.1a An activated ability is a mana ability if it meets all of the following criteria: it doesn’t have a target, it could add mana to a player’s mana pool when it resolves, and it’s not a loyalty ability. (See rule 606, “Loyalty Abilities.”)
So, are there currently abilities on cards that do have a target, but could add mana on resolve and are no loyalty abilities, thus using the stack?
I'm asking because until recently I falsely believed that all abilities that generate mana are mana abilities and are thus exceptions to the "abilities go to the stack" rule. But it wouldn't be MTG if rules didn't have exceptions to exceptions, so it'd be good to know which cards to look out for. Even if some of them are joke cards like Unglued it'd be nice to know them just for the sake of knowing.
magic-the-gathering
magic-the-gathering
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
asked Nov 14 at 11:54
Alex
18816
18816
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
New contributor
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
Alex is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
The answers provide examples of things that are not mana abilities. One thing to note is that, as long as it doesn't target, it is a mana ability no matter how complicated. See Selvala, Explorer Returned for an example of something truly absurd that is still a mana ability and does not use the stack.
– Zags
Nov 14 at 22:07
In case you are wondering about triggered abilities instead of activated abilities: Vernal Bloom is an example of a triggered mana ability while Eladamri’s Vineyard generates mana while not being a mana ability. see rule 605.1b
– Ivo Beckers
Nov 15 at 13:33
While I am also interested in triggered abilities, I don't see why Eladamri’s Vineyard is no mana ability, because "each player" means that it's not targeted either.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 13:51
1
605.1b specifies that a triggered ability is only a mana ability if it either comes from the resolution of an activated mana ability or from mana being added to a mana pool. That's why Eladamri's Vineyard is not a mana ability. As far why they chose it to be this way, I don't know.
– Manuel Hoffmann
Nov 15 at 15:24
Oh. My god! O_O That is very good to know, because I like to play Mana Echoes, whose ability, as it turns out, is not a mana ability, either, then.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 15:37
add a comment |
1
The answers provide examples of things that are not mana abilities. One thing to note is that, as long as it doesn't target, it is a mana ability no matter how complicated. See Selvala, Explorer Returned for an example of something truly absurd that is still a mana ability and does not use the stack.
– Zags
Nov 14 at 22:07
In case you are wondering about triggered abilities instead of activated abilities: Vernal Bloom is an example of a triggered mana ability while Eladamri’s Vineyard generates mana while not being a mana ability. see rule 605.1b
– Ivo Beckers
Nov 15 at 13:33
While I am also interested in triggered abilities, I don't see why Eladamri’s Vineyard is no mana ability, because "each player" means that it's not targeted either.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 13:51
1
605.1b specifies that a triggered ability is only a mana ability if it either comes from the resolution of an activated mana ability or from mana being added to a mana pool. That's why Eladamri's Vineyard is not a mana ability. As far why they chose it to be this way, I don't know.
– Manuel Hoffmann
Nov 15 at 15:24
Oh. My god! O_O That is very good to know, because I like to play Mana Echoes, whose ability, as it turns out, is not a mana ability, either, then.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 15:37
1
1
The answers provide examples of things that are not mana abilities. One thing to note is that, as long as it doesn't target, it is a mana ability no matter how complicated. See Selvala, Explorer Returned for an example of something truly absurd that is still a mana ability and does not use the stack.
– Zags
Nov 14 at 22:07
The answers provide examples of things that are not mana abilities. One thing to note is that, as long as it doesn't target, it is a mana ability no matter how complicated. See Selvala, Explorer Returned for an example of something truly absurd that is still a mana ability and does not use the stack.
– Zags
Nov 14 at 22:07
In case you are wondering about triggered abilities instead of activated abilities: Vernal Bloom is an example of a triggered mana ability while Eladamri’s Vineyard generates mana while not being a mana ability. see rule 605.1b
– Ivo Beckers
Nov 15 at 13:33
In case you are wondering about triggered abilities instead of activated abilities: Vernal Bloom is an example of a triggered mana ability while Eladamri’s Vineyard generates mana while not being a mana ability. see rule 605.1b
– Ivo Beckers
Nov 15 at 13:33
While I am also interested in triggered abilities, I don't see why Eladamri’s Vineyard is no mana ability, because "each player" means that it's not targeted either.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 13:51
While I am also interested in triggered abilities, I don't see why Eladamri’s Vineyard is no mana ability, because "each player" means that it's not targeted either.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 13:51
1
1
605.1b specifies that a triggered ability is only a mana ability if it either comes from the resolution of an activated mana ability or from mana being added to a mana pool. That's why Eladamri's Vineyard is not a mana ability. As far why they chose it to be this way, I don't know.
– Manuel Hoffmann
Nov 15 at 15:24
605.1b specifies that a triggered ability is only a mana ability if it either comes from the resolution of an activated mana ability or from mana being added to a mana pool. That's why Eladamri's Vineyard is not a mana ability. As far why they chose it to be this way, I don't know.
– Manuel Hoffmann
Nov 15 at 15:24
Oh. My god! O_O That is very good to know, because I like to play Mana Echoes, whose ability, as it turns out, is not a mana ability, either, then.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 15:37
Oh. My god! O_O That is very good to know, because I like to play Mana Echoes, whose ability, as it turns out, is not a mana ability, either, then.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 15:37
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
27
down vote
accepted
Yes, Deathrite Shaman is one such card. One of its abilities:
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color.
In fact, its oracle page even addresses this ability:
Because the first ability requires a target, it is not a mana ability. It uses the stack and can be responded to. (2016-06-08)
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
add a comment |
up vote
21
down vote
In addition to Ikegami's answer, I found two additional cards with abilities that add mana but are not considered mana abilities.
Soulbright Flamekin has the ability
{2}: Target creature gains trample until end of turn. If this is the third time this ability has resolved this turn, you may add RRRRRRRR.
Witch Engine has the ability
{T}: Add BBBB. Target opponent gains control of Witch Engine. (Activate this ability only any time you could cast an instant.)
Note that in both cases the abilities contain the keyword "Target". This makes the ability not a mana ability. Consider the counter case of Cabal Pit.
{T}: Add B. Cabal Pit deals 1 damage to you.
This is a mana ability because it never uses the word target.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
1
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
4
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
1
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
|
show 3 more comments
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
27
down vote
accepted
Yes, Deathrite Shaman is one such card. One of its abilities:
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color.
In fact, its oracle page even addresses this ability:
Because the first ability requires a target, it is not a mana ability. It uses the stack and can be responded to. (2016-06-08)
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
add a comment |
up vote
27
down vote
accepted
Yes, Deathrite Shaman is one such card. One of its abilities:
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color.
In fact, its oracle page even addresses this ability:
Because the first ability requires a target, it is not a mana ability. It uses the stack and can be responded to. (2016-06-08)
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
add a comment |
up vote
27
down vote
accepted
up vote
27
down vote
accepted
Yes, Deathrite Shaman is one such card. One of its abilities:
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color.
In fact, its oracle page even addresses this ability:
Because the first ability requires a target, it is not a mana ability. It uses the stack and can be responded to. (2016-06-08)
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
Yes, Deathrite Shaman is one such card. One of its abilities:
{T}: Exile target land card from a graveyard. Add one mana of any color.
In fact, its oracle page even addresses this ability:
Because the first ability requires a target, it is not a mana ability. It uses the stack and can be responded to. (2016-06-08)
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
answered Nov 14 at 13:50
ryanyuyu
1,404619
1,404619
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
add a comment |
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
Thank you for the help! :-)
– Alex
Nov 14 at 14:10
add a comment |
up vote
21
down vote
In addition to Ikegami's answer, I found two additional cards with abilities that add mana but are not considered mana abilities.
Soulbright Flamekin has the ability
{2}: Target creature gains trample until end of turn. If this is the third time this ability has resolved this turn, you may add RRRRRRRR.
Witch Engine has the ability
{T}: Add BBBB. Target opponent gains control of Witch Engine. (Activate this ability only any time you could cast an instant.)
Note that in both cases the abilities contain the keyword "Target". This makes the ability not a mana ability. Consider the counter case of Cabal Pit.
{T}: Add B. Cabal Pit deals 1 damage to you.
This is a mana ability because it never uses the word target.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
1
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
4
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
1
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
|
show 3 more comments
up vote
21
down vote
In addition to Ikegami's answer, I found two additional cards with abilities that add mana but are not considered mana abilities.
Soulbright Flamekin has the ability
{2}: Target creature gains trample until end of turn. If this is the third time this ability has resolved this turn, you may add RRRRRRRR.
Witch Engine has the ability
{T}: Add BBBB. Target opponent gains control of Witch Engine. (Activate this ability only any time you could cast an instant.)
Note that in both cases the abilities contain the keyword "Target". This makes the ability not a mana ability. Consider the counter case of Cabal Pit.
{T}: Add B. Cabal Pit deals 1 damage to you.
This is a mana ability because it never uses the word target.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
1
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
4
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
1
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
|
show 3 more comments
up vote
21
down vote
up vote
21
down vote
In addition to Ikegami's answer, I found two additional cards with abilities that add mana but are not considered mana abilities.
Soulbright Flamekin has the ability
{2}: Target creature gains trample until end of turn. If this is the third time this ability has resolved this turn, you may add RRRRRRRR.
Witch Engine has the ability
{T}: Add BBBB. Target opponent gains control of Witch Engine. (Activate this ability only any time you could cast an instant.)
Note that in both cases the abilities contain the keyword "Target". This makes the ability not a mana ability. Consider the counter case of Cabal Pit.
{T}: Add B. Cabal Pit deals 1 damage to you.
This is a mana ability because it never uses the word target.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
In addition to Ikegami's answer, I found two additional cards with abilities that add mana but are not considered mana abilities.
Soulbright Flamekin has the ability
{2}: Target creature gains trample until end of turn. If this is the third time this ability has resolved this turn, you may add RRRRRRRR.
Witch Engine has the ability
{T}: Add BBBB. Target opponent gains control of Witch Engine. (Activate this ability only any time you could cast an instant.)
Note that in both cases the abilities contain the keyword "Target". This makes the ability not a mana ability. Consider the counter case of Cabal Pit.
{T}: Add B. Cabal Pit deals 1 damage to you.
This is a mana ability because it never uses the word target.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
answered Nov 14 at 15:28
DenisS
37517
37517
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
New contributor
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
DenisS is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
1
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
4
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
1
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
|
show 3 more comments
1
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
1
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
4
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
1
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
1
1
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
Are you sure it has to specifically use the word target to count? For example, if it said "deal 1 damage to a creature that you choose"? That wording would not be used at this point in time, but the point remains, since there may be other cards that similarly don't exactly use the word target, especially if they are older.
– Aaron
Nov 14 at 22:24
1
1
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@Aaron yes. See rule 605.1a quoted above.
– Arcanist Lupus
Nov 15 at 1:23
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
@ArcanistLupus do you mean that the activating player is not a target for cabal pit? It seems odd and I do not see how rule 605.1a is relevant.
– Rad80
Nov 15 at 8:28
4
4
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
@Rad80, the activating player of Cabal Pit is indeed not a target. (How could they be? The activating player is fixed by the action of activating the ability, so there's no possibility of choice in any scenario). See rule 114.
– Peter Taylor
Nov 15 at 8:42
1
1
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
@DenisS Thank you for the additional examples! :-)
– Alex
Nov 15 at 9:33
|
show 3 more comments
Alex is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Alex is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Alex is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Alex is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fboardgames.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f44040%2fdoes-mtg-have-a-card-with-a-mana-generating-ability-that-has-a-target-and-is-thu%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
The answers provide examples of things that are not mana abilities. One thing to note is that, as long as it doesn't target, it is a mana ability no matter how complicated. See Selvala, Explorer Returned for an example of something truly absurd that is still a mana ability and does not use the stack.
– Zags
Nov 14 at 22:07
In case you are wondering about triggered abilities instead of activated abilities: Vernal Bloom is an example of a triggered mana ability while Eladamri’s Vineyard generates mana while not being a mana ability. see rule 605.1b
– Ivo Beckers
Nov 15 at 13:33
While I am also interested in triggered abilities, I don't see why Eladamri’s Vineyard is no mana ability, because "each player" means that it's not targeted either.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 13:51
1
605.1b specifies that a triggered ability is only a mana ability if it either comes from the resolution of an activated mana ability or from mana being added to a mana pool. That's why Eladamri's Vineyard is not a mana ability. As far why they chose it to be this way, I don't know.
– Manuel Hoffmann
Nov 15 at 15:24
Oh. My god! O_O That is very good to know, because I like to play Mana Echoes, whose ability, as it turns out, is not a mana ability, either, then.
– Alex
Nov 15 at 15:37