What is the function of this complicated tensioning system?











up vote
25
down vote

favorite
2












I saw this arrangement for tensioning overhead cables from my train window (schematic below). Why not just have one pulley wheel leading directly to the weights? What function do the additional pulleys serve? For that matter, what are the cables for? They're clearly not power lines.



enter image description here



enter image description here










share|cite|improve this question


















  • 3




    Why would workers want to lug around and lift a weight that's two to three times heavier than the one in the picture, which already looks pretty unwieldy?
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:41






  • 1




    That's a tradeoff that has probably been thought about. Having to do maintenance once in a while likely sounds better than expending twice to three times the effort every single time you do this.
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:46






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean a thicker and less flexible cable to support them (so maybe a bigger diameter pulley), a different direction of the reaction force in the bracket attaching the pulley to the pole, etc. Also a weight of 3 units will cost 3 times as much as a weight of 1 unit because it needs 3 times as much material.
    – alephzero
    Dec 4 at 11:01






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean more force on the pole (from supporting the weight, not tensioning the cable), so they might require stronger & more expensive poles.
    – jamesqf
    Dec 4 at 18:26






  • 1




    @DmitryGrigoryev I don't have another picture, but this stretch of lines between London King's Cross and Cambridge, UK, and just outside Cambridge.
    – mitte
    Dec 5 at 9:00















up vote
25
down vote

favorite
2












I saw this arrangement for tensioning overhead cables from my train window (schematic below). Why not just have one pulley wheel leading directly to the weights? What function do the additional pulleys serve? For that matter, what are the cables for? They're clearly not power lines.



enter image description here



enter image description here










share|cite|improve this question


















  • 3




    Why would workers want to lug around and lift a weight that's two to three times heavier than the one in the picture, which already looks pretty unwieldy?
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:41






  • 1




    That's a tradeoff that has probably been thought about. Having to do maintenance once in a while likely sounds better than expending twice to three times the effort every single time you do this.
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:46






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean a thicker and less flexible cable to support them (so maybe a bigger diameter pulley), a different direction of the reaction force in the bracket attaching the pulley to the pole, etc. Also a weight of 3 units will cost 3 times as much as a weight of 1 unit because it needs 3 times as much material.
    – alephzero
    Dec 4 at 11:01






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean more force on the pole (from supporting the weight, not tensioning the cable), so they might require stronger & more expensive poles.
    – jamesqf
    Dec 4 at 18:26






  • 1




    @DmitryGrigoryev I don't have another picture, but this stretch of lines between London King's Cross and Cambridge, UK, and just outside Cambridge.
    – mitte
    Dec 5 at 9:00













up vote
25
down vote

favorite
2









up vote
25
down vote

favorite
2






2





I saw this arrangement for tensioning overhead cables from my train window (schematic below). Why not just have one pulley wheel leading directly to the weights? What function do the additional pulleys serve? For that matter, what are the cables for? They're clearly not power lines.



enter image description here



enter image description here










share|cite|improve this question













I saw this arrangement for tensioning overhead cables from my train window (schematic below). Why not just have one pulley wheel leading directly to the weights? What function do the additional pulleys serve? For that matter, what are the cables for? They're clearly not power lines.



enter image description here



enter image description here







newtonian-mechanics weight






share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question











share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question










asked Dec 4 at 10:23









mitte

22815




22815








  • 3




    Why would workers want to lug around and lift a weight that's two to three times heavier than the one in the picture, which already looks pretty unwieldy?
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:41






  • 1




    That's a tradeoff that has probably been thought about. Having to do maintenance once in a while likely sounds better than expending twice to three times the effort every single time you do this.
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:46






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean a thicker and less flexible cable to support them (so maybe a bigger diameter pulley), a different direction of the reaction force in the bracket attaching the pulley to the pole, etc. Also a weight of 3 units will cost 3 times as much as a weight of 1 unit because it needs 3 times as much material.
    – alephzero
    Dec 4 at 11:01






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean more force on the pole (from supporting the weight, not tensioning the cable), so they might require stronger & more expensive poles.
    – jamesqf
    Dec 4 at 18:26






  • 1




    @DmitryGrigoryev I don't have another picture, but this stretch of lines between London King's Cross and Cambridge, UK, and just outside Cambridge.
    – mitte
    Dec 5 at 9:00














  • 3




    Why would workers want to lug around and lift a weight that's two to three times heavier than the one in the picture, which already looks pretty unwieldy?
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:41






  • 1




    That's a tradeoff that has probably been thought about. Having to do maintenance once in a while likely sounds better than expending twice to three times the effort every single time you do this.
    – probably_someone
    Dec 4 at 10:46






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean a thicker and less flexible cable to support them (so maybe a bigger diameter pulley), a different direction of the reaction force in the bracket attaching the pulley to the pole, etc. Also a weight of 3 units will cost 3 times as much as a weight of 1 unit because it needs 3 times as much material.
    – alephzero
    Dec 4 at 11:01






  • 2




    Heavier weights also mean more force on the pole (from supporting the weight, not tensioning the cable), so they might require stronger & more expensive poles.
    – jamesqf
    Dec 4 at 18:26






  • 1




    @DmitryGrigoryev I don't have another picture, but this stretch of lines between London King's Cross and Cambridge, UK, and just outside Cambridge.
    – mitte
    Dec 5 at 9:00








3




3




Why would workers want to lug around and lift a weight that's two to three times heavier than the one in the picture, which already looks pretty unwieldy?
– probably_someone
Dec 4 at 10:41




Why would workers want to lug around and lift a weight that's two to three times heavier than the one in the picture, which already looks pretty unwieldy?
– probably_someone
Dec 4 at 10:41




1




1




That's a tradeoff that has probably been thought about. Having to do maintenance once in a while likely sounds better than expending twice to three times the effort every single time you do this.
– probably_someone
Dec 4 at 10:46




That's a tradeoff that has probably been thought about. Having to do maintenance once in a while likely sounds better than expending twice to three times the effort every single time you do this.
– probably_someone
Dec 4 at 10:46




2




2




Heavier weights also mean a thicker and less flexible cable to support them (so maybe a bigger diameter pulley), a different direction of the reaction force in the bracket attaching the pulley to the pole, etc. Also a weight of 3 units will cost 3 times as much as a weight of 1 unit because it needs 3 times as much material.
– alephzero
Dec 4 at 11:01




Heavier weights also mean a thicker and less flexible cable to support them (so maybe a bigger diameter pulley), a different direction of the reaction force in the bracket attaching the pulley to the pole, etc. Also a weight of 3 units will cost 3 times as much as a weight of 1 unit because it needs 3 times as much material.
– alephzero
Dec 4 at 11:01




2




2




Heavier weights also mean more force on the pole (from supporting the weight, not tensioning the cable), so they might require stronger & more expensive poles.
– jamesqf
Dec 4 at 18:26




Heavier weights also mean more force on the pole (from supporting the weight, not tensioning the cable), so they might require stronger & more expensive poles.
– jamesqf
Dec 4 at 18:26




1




1




@DmitryGrigoryev I don't have another picture, but this stretch of lines between London King's Cross and Cambridge, UK, and just outside Cambridge.
– mitte
Dec 5 at 9:00




@DmitryGrigoryev I don't have another picture, but this stretch of lines between London King's Cross and Cambridge, UK, and just outside Cambridge.
– mitte
Dec 5 at 9:00










5 Answers
5






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
31
down vote



accepted










Having more pulleys increases the mechanical advantage of the system. In this case the mechanical advantage is 3. This means that the weights involved need to be a third as massive and the cables passing over the pulleys need to have a third the strength. This makes everything cheaper, smaller, and more tractable: it means, for instance, that you can use cheap, rather low-density, materials for the weights (they are often piles of concrete disks around a central metal rod). Cheap weights are both, well, cheap, but also less interesting to thieves: no-one wants to steal concrete disks, a lot of people want to steal lead, say, and metal theft is a big problem for many railways (obviously this part of the reason has no physics content, but it's important). Another reason for reducing the mass of the weights may be to do with how hard it is to install and maintain things: the lighter the weights are the less heavy machinery you need to get close to them. I don't know to what extent this is a consideration, and it's also not really a physics issues. Finally the pulleys can be a lot smaller as well as thin cables are more flexible.



In answer to the second question: yes these probably are the ends of the power lines (although there may be some big insulator out of the shot). I'm not an expert on railway power systems but I think what they tend to do is have overlapping sections of power cable, so at a mast one set terminates while the other set carries on (assuming anything ends at all there: a lot of the masts are just for support I think).






share|cite|improve this answer



















  • 1




    You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
    – Pere
    Dec 5 at 12:32


















up vote
16
down vote













This is a so-called block and tackle arrangement which is often used for tensioning of overhead lines. Tensioning is required to keep a desired line geometry and, in case of contact wires, to avoid standing mechanical waves (waves in a tensioned line travel faster).



Apart from mechanical advantage, such systems often provide a safety braking mechanism which prevents the line from unravelling completely in case it breaks.



The location in your photo most probably corresponds to an overhead line section break: the power line on the left side has ended, was pulled outside of the tracks and terminated by a tensioning mechanism. About a hundred meters to the left, a new section must have started (probably with another tensioning mechanism) and pulled to the middle of the track at the point where the photo is taken. That's the wire you see just above the mechanism in question.






share|cite|improve this answer






























    up vote
    2
    down vote













    Railway overhead electrification is a complex business, I am far from an expert but this is my simplified understanding.



    There will normally be at least two wires, a "contact" wire which runs horizontally to make contact with the train's pantograph and a "catenary" wire which supports the contact wire. An appropriate tension must be maintained in the wires, too tight and the stresses from trains would be unacceptable, too loose and the wires would droop.



    Wires contract and expand with temperature, this implies two things.




    1. A tensioning system is needed that can maintain tension as the length of the wires changes.

    2. The distance between tensioning points is limited. Otherwise distortions to the geometry from expansion and contraction would become unacceptable.


    So periodically along the length of the railway the wires will pull off to a tensioning device at the side. There will be an overlap between sections of wire so there is always a wire to hold the pantograph in place.



    In this case the tensioning device consists of three pulleys and a set of weights, the pulleys will reduce the weight needed to achieve the desired tension in the wires. Then there appears to be an insulator and then a bar joining the catenary and contact wires.






    share|cite|improve this answer






























      up vote
      2
      down vote













      You already got an answer to your main question - why are there pulleys? I will attempt to answer the second question - what is this wire?



      There are two possible answers.



      First, I found the following image at http://www.rail.co.uk/rail-news/ecml-suffers-another-failure/



      enter image description here



      The label tells us that this is a "along-track conductor" pair. Such conductors may be used to distribute power over longer distances (without the power line rubbing against the pantograph - think of it as a parallel circuit). The cable expands and contracts with temperature which is why you need a tensioning mechanism with a lot of "play" (and which maintains constant tension, which a spring won't do quite as well - at least not as easily).



      There is a lot of detail about overhead electrification in this document if you want to read more.



      But then, I found another picture on this site - one that is almost identical to yours:



      enter image description here



      The caption says




      Figure 11: Overhead line suspension system. The weights and pulley system is designed to maintain contact wire tension. Photo: Author.




      The insulator is a bit more clearly visible in this picture, but it seems plausible that this is a picture of the same mechanism that you saw. That means this is indeed providing tension for the contact wire, which is the wire that the pantograph rubs against.






      share|cite|improve this answer




























        up vote
        -1
        down vote













        It's to maintain the tension in the overhead powerline. The line acts like violin string, with the collector on the train acting as a bow. If the train is travelling faster than the wave in the power line, then a standing wave may be induced in the power line, causing it to snap. The line will contract and expand with temperature, so a fixed load is placed on it. See the Wikipedia entry






        share|cite|improve this answer

















        • 3




          That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
          – Emilio Pisanty
          Dec 4 at 21:57






        • 2




          but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
          – dlatikay
          Dec 4 at 23:25












        • There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
          – CSM
          Dec 4 at 23:39











        Your Answer





        StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
        return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
        StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
        StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
        });
        });
        }, "mathjax-editing");

        StackExchange.ready(function() {
        var channelOptions = {
        tags: "".split(" "),
        id: "151"
        };
        initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

        StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
        // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
        if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
        StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
        createEditor();
        });
        }
        else {
        createEditor();
        }
        });

        function createEditor() {
        StackExchange.prepareEditor({
        heartbeatType: 'answer',
        autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
        convertImagesToLinks: false,
        noModals: true,
        showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
        reputationToPostImages: null,
        bindNavPrevention: true,
        postfix: "",
        imageUploader: {
        brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
        contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
        allowUrls: true
        },
        noCode: true, onDemand: true,
        discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
        ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
        });


        }
        });














        draft saved

        draft discarded


















        StackExchange.ready(
        function () {
        StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphysics.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f445062%2fwhat-is-the-function-of-this-complicated-tensioning-system%23new-answer', 'question_page');
        }
        );

        Post as a guest















        Required, but never shown

























        5 Answers
        5






        active

        oldest

        votes








        5 Answers
        5






        active

        oldest

        votes









        active

        oldest

        votes






        active

        oldest

        votes








        up vote
        31
        down vote



        accepted










        Having more pulleys increases the mechanical advantage of the system. In this case the mechanical advantage is 3. This means that the weights involved need to be a third as massive and the cables passing over the pulleys need to have a third the strength. This makes everything cheaper, smaller, and more tractable: it means, for instance, that you can use cheap, rather low-density, materials for the weights (they are often piles of concrete disks around a central metal rod). Cheap weights are both, well, cheap, but also less interesting to thieves: no-one wants to steal concrete disks, a lot of people want to steal lead, say, and metal theft is a big problem for many railways (obviously this part of the reason has no physics content, but it's important). Another reason for reducing the mass of the weights may be to do with how hard it is to install and maintain things: the lighter the weights are the less heavy machinery you need to get close to them. I don't know to what extent this is a consideration, and it's also not really a physics issues. Finally the pulleys can be a lot smaller as well as thin cables are more flexible.



        In answer to the second question: yes these probably are the ends of the power lines (although there may be some big insulator out of the shot). I'm not an expert on railway power systems but I think what they tend to do is have overlapping sections of power cable, so at a mast one set terminates while the other set carries on (assuming anything ends at all there: a lot of the masts are just for support I think).






        share|cite|improve this answer



















        • 1




          You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
          – Pere
          Dec 5 at 12:32















        up vote
        31
        down vote



        accepted










        Having more pulleys increases the mechanical advantage of the system. In this case the mechanical advantage is 3. This means that the weights involved need to be a third as massive and the cables passing over the pulleys need to have a third the strength. This makes everything cheaper, smaller, and more tractable: it means, for instance, that you can use cheap, rather low-density, materials for the weights (they are often piles of concrete disks around a central metal rod). Cheap weights are both, well, cheap, but also less interesting to thieves: no-one wants to steal concrete disks, a lot of people want to steal lead, say, and metal theft is a big problem for many railways (obviously this part of the reason has no physics content, but it's important). Another reason for reducing the mass of the weights may be to do with how hard it is to install and maintain things: the lighter the weights are the less heavy machinery you need to get close to them. I don't know to what extent this is a consideration, and it's also not really a physics issues. Finally the pulleys can be a lot smaller as well as thin cables are more flexible.



        In answer to the second question: yes these probably are the ends of the power lines (although there may be some big insulator out of the shot). I'm not an expert on railway power systems but I think what they tend to do is have overlapping sections of power cable, so at a mast one set terminates while the other set carries on (assuming anything ends at all there: a lot of the masts are just for support I think).






        share|cite|improve this answer



















        • 1




          You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
          – Pere
          Dec 5 at 12:32













        up vote
        31
        down vote



        accepted







        up vote
        31
        down vote



        accepted






        Having more pulleys increases the mechanical advantage of the system. In this case the mechanical advantage is 3. This means that the weights involved need to be a third as massive and the cables passing over the pulleys need to have a third the strength. This makes everything cheaper, smaller, and more tractable: it means, for instance, that you can use cheap, rather low-density, materials for the weights (they are often piles of concrete disks around a central metal rod). Cheap weights are both, well, cheap, but also less interesting to thieves: no-one wants to steal concrete disks, a lot of people want to steal lead, say, and metal theft is a big problem for many railways (obviously this part of the reason has no physics content, but it's important). Another reason for reducing the mass of the weights may be to do with how hard it is to install and maintain things: the lighter the weights are the less heavy machinery you need to get close to them. I don't know to what extent this is a consideration, and it's also not really a physics issues. Finally the pulleys can be a lot smaller as well as thin cables are more flexible.



        In answer to the second question: yes these probably are the ends of the power lines (although there may be some big insulator out of the shot). I'm not an expert on railway power systems but I think what they tend to do is have overlapping sections of power cable, so at a mast one set terminates while the other set carries on (assuming anything ends at all there: a lot of the masts are just for support I think).






        share|cite|improve this answer














        Having more pulleys increases the mechanical advantage of the system. In this case the mechanical advantage is 3. This means that the weights involved need to be a third as massive and the cables passing over the pulleys need to have a third the strength. This makes everything cheaper, smaller, and more tractable: it means, for instance, that you can use cheap, rather low-density, materials for the weights (they are often piles of concrete disks around a central metal rod). Cheap weights are both, well, cheap, but also less interesting to thieves: no-one wants to steal concrete disks, a lot of people want to steal lead, say, and metal theft is a big problem for many railways (obviously this part of the reason has no physics content, but it's important). Another reason for reducing the mass of the weights may be to do with how hard it is to install and maintain things: the lighter the weights are the less heavy machinery you need to get close to them. I don't know to what extent this is a consideration, and it's also not really a physics issues. Finally the pulleys can be a lot smaller as well as thin cables are more flexible.



        In answer to the second question: yes these probably are the ends of the power lines (although there may be some big insulator out of the shot). I'm not an expert on railway power systems but I think what they tend to do is have overlapping sections of power cable, so at a mast one set terminates while the other set carries on (assuming anything ends at all there: a lot of the masts are just for support I think).







        share|cite|improve this answer














        share|cite|improve this answer



        share|cite|improve this answer








        edited Dec 5 at 12:42

























        answered Dec 4 at 10:54









        tfb

        15.1k43151




        15.1k43151








        • 1




          You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
          – Pere
          Dec 5 at 12:32














        • 1




          You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
          – Pere
          Dec 5 at 12:32








        1




        1




        You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
        – Pere
        Dec 5 at 12:32




        You are right about its funcion: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overhead_line#Tensioning
        – Pere
        Dec 5 at 12:32










        up vote
        16
        down vote













        This is a so-called block and tackle arrangement which is often used for tensioning of overhead lines. Tensioning is required to keep a desired line geometry and, in case of contact wires, to avoid standing mechanical waves (waves in a tensioned line travel faster).



        Apart from mechanical advantage, such systems often provide a safety braking mechanism which prevents the line from unravelling completely in case it breaks.



        The location in your photo most probably corresponds to an overhead line section break: the power line on the left side has ended, was pulled outside of the tracks and terminated by a tensioning mechanism. About a hundred meters to the left, a new section must have started (probably with another tensioning mechanism) and pulled to the middle of the track at the point where the photo is taken. That's the wire you see just above the mechanism in question.






        share|cite|improve this answer



























          up vote
          16
          down vote













          This is a so-called block and tackle arrangement which is often used for tensioning of overhead lines. Tensioning is required to keep a desired line geometry and, in case of contact wires, to avoid standing mechanical waves (waves in a tensioned line travel faster).



          Apart from mechanical advantage, such systems often provide a safety braking mechanism which prevents the line from unravelling completely in case it breaks.



          The location in your photo most probably corresponds to an overhead line section break: the power line on the left side has ended, was pulled outside of the tracks and terminated by a tensioning mechanism. About a hundred meters to the left, a new section must have started (probably with another tensioning mechanism) and pulled to the middle of the track at the point where the photo is taken. That's the wire you see just above the mechanism in question.






          share|cite|improve this answer

























            up vote
            16
            down vote










            up vote
            16
            down vote









            This is a so-called block and tackle arrangement which is often used for tensioning of overhead lines. Tensioning is required to keep a desired line geometry and, in case of contact wires, to avoid standing mechanical waves (waves in a tensioned line travel faster).



            Apart from mechanical advantage, such systems often provide a safety braking mechanism which prevents the line from unravelling completely in case it breaks.



            The location in your photo most probably corresponds to an overhead line section break: the power line on the left side has ended, was pulled outside of the tracks and terminated by a tensioning mechanism. About a hundred meters to the left, a new section must have started (probably with another tensioning mechanism) and pulled to the middle of the track at the point where the photo is taken. That's the wire you see just above the mechanism in question.






            share|cite|improve this answer














            This is a so-called block and tackle arrangement which is often used for tensioning of overhead lines. Tensioning is required to keep a desired line geometry and, in case of contact wires, to avoid standing mechanical waves (waves in a tensioned line travel faster).



            Apart from mechanical advantage, such systems often provide a safety braking mechanism which prevents the line from unravelling completely in case it breaks.



            The location in your photo most probably corresponds to an overhead line section break: the power line on the left side has ended, was pulled outside of the tracks and terminated by a tensioning mechanism. About a hundred meters to the left, a new section must have started (probably with another tensioning mechanism) and pulled to the middle of the track at the point where the photo is taken. That's the wire you see just above the mechanism in question.







            share|cite|improve this answer














            share|cite|improve this answer



            share|cite|improve this answer








            edited Dec 5 at 13:15

























            answered Dec 4 at 14:34









            Dmitry Grigoryev

            2,5581523




            2,5581523






















                up vote
                2
                down vote













                Railway overhead electrification is a complex business, I am far from an expert but this is my simplified understanding.



                There will normally be at least two wires, a "contact" wire which runs horizontally to make contact with the train's pantograph and a "catenary" wire which supports the contact wire. An appropriate tension must be maintained in the wires, too tight and the stresses from trains would be unacceptable, too loose and the wires would droop.



                Wires contract and expand with temperature, this implies two things.




                1. A tensioning system is needed that can maintain tension as the length of the wires changes.

                2. The distance between tensioning points is limited. Otherwise distortions to the geometry from expansion and contraction would become unacceptable.


                So periodically along the length of the railway the wires will pull off to a tensioning device at the side. There will be an overlap between sections of wire so there is always a wire to hold the pantograph in place.



                In this case the tensioning device consists of three pulleys and a set of weights, the pulleys will reduce the weight needed to achieve the desired tension in the wires. Then there appears to be an insulator and then a bar joining the catenary and contact wires.






                share|cite|improve this answer



























                  up vote
                  2
                  down vote













                  Railway overhead electrification is a complex business, I am far from an expert but this is my simplified understanding.



                  There will normally be at least two wires, a "contact" wire which runs horizontally to make contact with the train's pantograph and a "catenary" wire which supports the contact wire. An appropriate tension must be maintained in the wires, too tight and the stresses from trains would be unacceptable, too loose and the wires would droop.



                  Wires contract and expand with temperature, this implies two things.




                  1. A tensioning system is needed that can maintain tension as the length of the wires changes.

                  2. The distance between tensioning points is limited. Otherwise distortions to the geometry from expansion and contraction would become unacceptable.


                  So periodically along the length of the railway the wires will pull off to a tensioning device at the side. There will be an overlap between sections of wire so there is always a wire to hold the pantograph in place.



                  In this case the tensioning device consists of three pulleys and a set of weights, the pulleys will reduce the weight needed to achieve the desired tension in the wires. Then there appears to be an insulator and then a bar joining the catenary and contact wires.






                  share|cite|improve this answer

























                    up vote
                    2
                    down vote










                    up vote
                    2
                    down vote









                    Railway overhead electrification is a complex business, I am far from an expert but this is my simplified understanding.



                    There will normally be at least two wires, a "contact" wire which runs horizontally to make contact with the train's pantograph and a "catenary" wire which supports the contact wire. An appropriate tension must be maintained in the wires, too tight and the stresses from trains would be unacceptable, too loose and the wires would droop.



                    Wires contract and expand with temperature, this implies two things.




                    1. A tensioning system is needed that can maintain tension as the length of the wires changes.

                    2. The distance between tensioning points is limited. Otherwise distortions to the geometry from expansion and contraction would become unacceptable.


                    So periodically along the length of the railway the wires will pull off to a tensioning device at the side. There will be an overlap between sections of wire so there is always a wire to hold the pantograph in place.



                    In this case the tensioning device consists of three pulleys and a set of weights, the pulleys will reduce the weight needed to achieve the desired tension in the wires. Then there appears to be an insulator and then a bar joining the catenary and contact wires.






                    share|cite|improve this answer














                    Railway overhead electrification is a complex business, I am far from an expert but this is my simplified understanding.



                    There will normally be at least two wires, a "contact" wire which runs horizontally to make contact with the train's pantograph and a "catenary" wire which supports the contact wire. An appropriate tension must be maintained in the wires, too tight and the stresses from trains would be unacceptable, too loose and the wires would droop.



                    Wires contract and expand with temperature, this implies two things.




                    1. A tensioning system is needed that can maintain tension as the length of the wires changes.

                    2. The distance between tensioning points is limited. Otherwise distortions to the geometry from expansion and contraction would become unacceptable.


                    So periodically along the length of the railway the wires will pull off to a tensioning device at the side. There will be an overlap between sections of wire so there is always a wire to hold the pantograph in place.



                    In this case the tensioning device consists of three pulleys and a set of weights, the pulleys will reduce the weight needed to achieve the desired tension in the wires. Then there appears to be an insulator and then a bar joining the catenary and contact wires.







                    share|cite|improve this answer














                    share|cite|improve this answer



                    share|cite|improve this answer








                    edited Dec 5 at 10:01

























                    answered Dec 5 at 9:49









                    Peter Green

                    809412




                    809412






















                        up vote
                        2
                        down vote













                        You already got an answer to your main question - why are there pulleys? I will attempt to answer the second question - what is this wire?



                        There are two possible answers.



                        First, I found the following image at http://www.rail.co.uk/rail-news/ecml-suffers-another-failure/



                        enter image description here



                        The label tells us that this is a "along-track conductor" pair. Such conductors may be used to distribute power over longer distances (without the power line rubbing against the pantograph - think of it as a parallel circuit). The cable expands and contracts with temperature which is why you need a tensioning mechanism with a lot of "play" (and which maintains constant tension, which a spring won't do quite as well - at least not as easily).



                        There is a lot of detail about overhead electrification in this document if you want to read more.



                        But then, I found another picture on this site - one that is almost identical to yours:



                        enter image description here



                        The caption says




                        Figure 11: Overhead line suspension system. The weights and pulley system is designed to maintain contact wire tension. Photo: Author.




                        The insulator is a bit more clearly visible in this picture, but it seems plausible that this is a picture of the same mechanism that you saw. That means this is indeed providing tension for the contact wire, which is the wire that the pantograph rubs against.






                        share|cite|improve this answer

























                          up vote
                          2
                          down vote













                          You already got an answer to your main question - why are there pulleys? I will attempt to answer the second question - what is this wire?



                          There are two possible answers.



                          First, I found the following image at http://www.rail.co.uk/rail-news/ecml-suffers-another-failure/



                          enter image description here



                          The label tells us that this is a "along-track conductor" pair. Such conductors may be used to distribute power over longer distances (without the power line rubbing against the pantograph - think of it as a parallel circuit). The cable expands and contracts with temperature which is why you need a tensioning mechanism with a lot of "play" (and which maintains constant tension, which a spring won't do quite as well - at least not as easily).



                          There is a lot of detail about overhead electrification in this document if you want to read more.



                          But then, I found another picture on this site - one that is almost identical to yours:



                          enter image description here



                          The caption says




                          Figure 11: Overhead line suspension system. The weights and pulley system is designed to maintain contact wire tension. Photo: Author.




                          The insulator is a bit more clearly visible in this picture, but it seems plausible that this is a picture of the same mechanism that you saw. That means this is indeed providing tension for the contact wire, which is the wire that the pantograph rubs against.






                          share|cite|improve this answer























                            up vote
                            2
                            down vote










                            up vote
                            2
                            down vote









                            You already got an answer to your main question - why are there pulleys? I will attempt to answer the second question - what is this wire?



                            There are two possible answers.



                            First, I found the following image at http://www.rail.co.uk/rail-news/ecml-suffers-another-failure/



                            enter image description here



                            The label tells us that this is a "along-track conductor" pair. Such conductors may be used to distribute power over longer distances (without the power line rubbing against the pantograph - think of it as a parallel circuit). The cable expands and contracts with temperature which is why you need a tensioning mechanism with a lot of "play" (and which maintains constant tension, which a spring won't do quite as well - at least not as easily).



                            There is a lot of detail about overhead electrification in this document if you want to read more.



                            But then, I found another picture on this site - one that is almost identical to yours:



                            enter image description here



                            The caption says




                            Figure 11: Overhead line suspension system. The weights and pulley system is designed to maintain contact wire tension. Photo: Author.




                            The insulator is a bit more clearly visible in this picture, but it seems plausible that this is a picture of the same mechanism that you saw. That means this is indeed providing tension for the contact wire, which is the wire that the pantograph rubs against.






                            share|cite|improve this answer












                            You already got an answer to your main question - why are there pulleys? I will attempt to answer the second question - what is this wire?



                            There are two possible answers.



                            First, I found the following image at http://www.rail.co.uk/rail-news/ecml-suffers-another-failure/



                            enter image description here



                            The label tells us that this is a "along-track conductor" pair. Such conductors may be used to distribute power over longer distances (without the power line rubbing against the pantograph - think of it as a parallel circuit). The cable expands and contracts with temperature which is why you need a tensioning mechanism with a lot of "play" (and which maintains constant tension, which a spring won't do quite as well - at least not as easily).



                            There is a lot of detail about overhead electrification in this document if you want to read more.



                            But then, I found another picture on this site - one that is almost identical to yours:



                            enter image description here



                            The caption says




                            Figure 11: Overhead line suspension system. The weights and pulley system is designed to maintain contact wire tension. Photo: Author.




                            The insulator is a bit more clearly visible in this picture, but it seems plausible that this is a picture of the same mechanism that you saw. That means this is indeed providing tension for the contact wire, which is the wire that the pantograph rubs against.







                            share|cite|improve this answer












                            share|cite|improve this answer



                            share|cite|improve this answer










                            answered Dec 5 at 20:22









                            Floris

                            106k11187321




                            106k11187321






















                                up vote
                                -1
                                down vote













                                It's to maintain the tension in the overhead powerline. The line acts like violin string, with the collector on the train acting as a bow. If the train is travelling faster than the wave in the power line, then a standing wave may be induced in the power line, causing it to snap. The line will contract and expand with temperature, so a fixed load is placed on it. See the Wikipedia entry






                                share|cite|improve this answer

















                                • 3




                                  That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
                                  – Emilio Pisanty
                                  Dec 4 at 21:57






                                • 2




                                  but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
                                  – dlatikay
                                  Dec 4 at 23:25












                                • There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
                                  – CSM
                                  Dec 4 at 23:39















                                up vote
                                -1
                                down vote













                                It's to maintain the tension in the overhead powerline. The line acts like violin string, with the collector on the train acting as a bow. If the train is travelling faster than the wave in the power line, then a standing wave may be induced in the power line, causing it to snap. The line will contract and expand with temperature, so a fixed load is placed on it. See the Wikipedia entry






                                share|cite|improve this answer

















                                • 3




                                  That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
                                  – Emilio Pisanty
                                  Dec 4 at 21:57






                                • 2




                                  but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
                                  – dlatikay
                                  Dec 4 at 23:25












                                • There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
                                  – CSM
                                  Dec 4 at 23:39













                                up vote
                                -1
                                down vote










                                up vote
                                -1
                                down vote









                                It's to maintain the tension in the overhead powerline. The line acts like violin string, with the collector on the train acting as a bow. If the train is travelling faster than the wave in the power line, then a standing wave may be induced in the power line, causing it to snap. The line will contract and expand with temperature, so a fixed load is placed on it. See the Wikipedia entry






                                share|cite|improve this answer












                                It's to maintain the tension in the overhead powerline. The line acts like violin string, with the collector on the train acting as a bow. If the train is travelling faster than the wave in the power line, then a standing wave may be induced in the power line, causing it to snap. The line will contract and expand with temperature, so a fixed load is placed on it. See the Wikipedia entry







                                share|cite|improve this answer












                                share|cite|improve this answer



                                share|cite|improve this answer










                                answered Dec 4 at 16:37









                                CSM

                                99




                                99








                                • 3




                                  That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
                                  – Emilio Pisanty
                                  Dec 4 at 21:57






                                • 2




                                  but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
                                  – dlatikay
                                  Dec 4 at 23:25












                                • There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
                                  – CSM
                                  Dec 4 at 23:39














                                • 3




                                  That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
                                  – Emilio Pisanty
                                  Dec 4 at 21:57






                                • 2




                                  but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
                                  – dlatikay
                                  Dec 4 at 23:25












                                • There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
                                  – CSM
                                  Dec 4 at 23:39








                                3




                                3




                                That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
                                – Emilio Pisanty
                                Dec 4 at 21:57




                                That's... extremely implausible. The line in question isn't a powerline, and if a train collector travels along it, it will smash into the post. It's possible that this is there to tense other lines, but that's another nontrivial step.
                                – Emilio Pisanty
                                Dec 4 at 21:57




                                2




                                2




                                but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
                                – dlatikay
                                Dec 4 at 23:25






                                but that wikipedia article you linked contains an interesting picture: this "german tensioning" shows that they use concentric wheels instead of the block-and-tackle for the mechanical advantage.
                                – dlatikay
                                Dec 4 at 23:25














                                There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
                                – CSM
                                Dec 4 at 23:39




                                There seems to be an insulator at the right of the single block. The OLE, at least in the UK, does pull to the outside as it is terminated
                                – CSM
                                Dec 4 at 23:39


















                                draft saved

                                draft discarded




















































                                Thanks for contributing an answer to Physics Stack Exchange!


                                • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                But avoid



                                • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                                Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


                                To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





                                Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


                                Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


                                • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                But avoid



                                • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                                To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                                draft saved


                                draft discarded














                                StackExchange.ready(
                                function () {
                                StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphysics.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f445062%2fwhat-is-the-function-of-this-complicated-tensioning-system%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                                }
                                );

                                Post as a guest















                                Required, but never shown





















































                                Required, but never shown














                                Required, but never shown












                                Required, but never shown







                                Required, but never shown

































                                Required, but never shown














                                Required, but never shown












                                Required, but never shown







                                Required, but never shown







                                Popular posts from this blog

                                Quarter-circle Tiles

                                build a pushdown automaton that recognizes the reverse language of a given pushdown automaton?

                                Mont Emei