How to prove that an even permutation of $A_n$ is a square of another permutation from $S_n$?











up vote
4
down vote

favorite












I am trying to go through a proof which contains a statement that an even permutation from $A_n$ is a square of another permutation from $S_n$. My basic ideas are like this:



Suppose an even permutation is $y$. As the signature of an even permutation is $+1$, we are able to write it as a product of $t_{1}t_{2}t_{3}t_{4}...t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ with each $t$ standing for a two cycle. Then, consider $t_{1}t_{2}$, it can be written as $(ij)(kl)$ if $t_{1}$ and $t_{2}$ are distinct, or as $(ij)(jk)$ if they are not distinct. However, $(ij)(kl) = (ikjl)^2$ and $(ij)(jk) = (ikj)^2$, which means each of the $t_1t_2$, $t_3t_4$,...,$t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ is a square of another permutation of $S_n$, say $x_i$.



However, how does it imply that $y$ is a square of another permutation? If $y = x_1^2...x_r^2$, does it necessarily mean that $y$ is a square of something? Is $x_i$ commutative in this case? I need some hints, thanks.










share|cite|improve this question
























  • Aren't all elements $A_n$ even permutations?
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • See math.stackexchange.com/a/538179/589
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • The result claimed is in general not true. But it is true for n=5
    – C Monsour
    Nov 16 at 5:42















up vote
4
down vote

favorite












I am trying to go through a proof which contains a statement that an even permutation from $A_n$ is a square of another permutation from $S_n$. My basic ideas are like this:



Suppose an even permutation is $y$. As the signature of an even permutation is $+1$, we are able to write it as a product of $t_{1}t_{2}t_{3}t_{4}...t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ with each $t$ standing for a two cycle. Then, consider $t_{1}t_{2}$, it can be written as $(ij)(kl)$ if $t_{1}$ and $t_{2}$ are distinct, or as $(ij)(jk)$ if they are not distinct. However, $(ij)(kl) = (ikjl)^2$ and $(ij)(jk) = (ikj)^2$, which means each of the $t_1t_2$, $t_3t_4$,...,$t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ is a square of another permutation of $S_n$, say $x_i$.



However, how does it imply that $y$ is a square of another permutation? If $y = x_1^2...x_r^2$, does it necessarily mean that $y$ is a square of something? Is $x_i$ commutative in this case? I need some hints, thanks.










share|cite|improve this question
























  • Aren't all elements $A_n$ even permutations?
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • See math.stackexchange.com/a/538179/589
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • The result claimed is in general not true. But it is true for n=5
    – C Monsour
    Nov 16 at 5:42













up vote
4
down vote

favorite









up vote
4
down vote

favorite











I am trying to go through a proof which contains a statement that an even permutation from $A_n$ is a square of another permutation from $S_n$. My basic ideas are like this:



Suppose an even permutation is $y$. As the signature of an even permutation is $+1$, we are able to write it as a product of $t_{1}t_{2}t_{3}t_{4}...t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ with each $t$ standing for a two cycle. Then, consider $t_{1}t_{2}$, it can be written as $(ij)(kl)$ if $t_{1}$ and $t_{2}$ are distinct, or as $(ij)(jk)$ if they are not distinct. However, $(ij)(kl) = (ikjl)^2$ and $(ij)(jk) = (ikj)^2$, which means each of the $t_1t_2$, $t_3t_4$,...,$t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ is a square of another permutation of $S_n$, say $x_i$.



However, how does it imply that $y$ is a square of another permutation? If $y = x_1^2...x_r^2$, does it necessarily mean that $y$ is a square of something? Is $x_i$ commutative in this case? I need some hints, thanks.










share|cite|improve this question















I am trying to go through a proof which contains a statement that an even permutation from $A_n$ is a square of another permutation from $S_n$. My basic ideas are like this:



Suppose an even permutation is $y$. As the signature of an even permutation is $+1$, we are able to write it as a product of $t_{1}t_{2}t_{3}t_{4}...t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ with each $t$ standing for a two cycle. Then, consider $t_{1}t_{2}$, it can be written as $(ij)(kl)$ if $t_{1}$ and $t_{2}$ are distinct, or as $(ij)(jk)$ if they are not distinct. However, $(ij)(kl) = (ikjl)^2$ and $(ij)(jk) = (ikj)^2$, which means each of the $t_1t_2$, $t_3t_4$,...,$t_{2r-1}t_{2r}$ is a square of another permutation of $S_n$, say $x_i$.



However, how does it imply that $y$ is a square of another permutation? If $y = x_1^2...x_r^2$, does it necessarily mean that $y$ is a square of something? Is $x_i$ commutative in this case? I need some hints, thanks.







abstract-algebra combinatorics group-theory permutations permutation-cycles






share|cite|improve this question















share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited Nov 15 at 13:37









amWhy

191k27223437




191k27223437










asked Nov 15 at 13:09









Jamie Carr

444




444












  • Aren't all elements $A_n$ even permutations?
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • See math.stackexchange.com/a/538179/589
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • The result claimed is in general not true. But it is true for n=5
    – C Monsour
    Nov 16 at 5:42


















  • Aren't all elements $A_n$ even permutations?
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • See math.stackexchange.com/a/538179/589
    – lhf
    Nov 15 at 15:52










  • The result claimed is in general not true. But it is true for n=5
    – C Monsour
    Nov 16 at 5:42
















Aren't all elements $A_n$ even permutations?
– lhf
Nov 15 at 15:52




Aren't all elements $A_n$ even permutations?
– lhf
Nov 15 at 15:52












See math.stackexchange.com/a/538179/589
– lhf
Nov 15 at 15:52




See math.stackexchange.com/a/538179/589
– lhf
Nov 15 at 15:52












The result claimed is in general not true. But it is true for n=5
– C Monsour
Nov 16 at 5:42




The result claimed is in general not true. But it is true for n=5
– C Monsour
Nov 16 at 5:42










3 Answers
3






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
3
down vote













Hint. A permutation is the square of another permutation if and only if, its cycle decomposition has an even number of cycles of length $m$ for every even number $m$.






share|cite|improve this answer

















  • 1




    Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
    – Jamie Carr
    Nov 15 at 13:19










  • See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
    – Robert Z
    Nov 15 at 17:10


















up vote
1
down vote













Some more hints:



Begin by studying the cycle structures of squares $sigma:=picircpi$ of arbitrary permutations. For this it is sufficient to find out what happens to a cycle of odd length under squaring, and what happens to a cycle of even length under squaring.






share|cite|improve this answer






























    up vote
    1
    down vote













    That's not remotely true: the density of squares in $S_n$ goes to zero as $nto +infty$ (like $frac{C}{sqrt{n}}$, actually), while your claim would imply that the $liminf$ of such density is at least $frac{1}{2}$. Indeed, if we consider
    $$sigma = (1,2)(3,4,5,6) in A_6 $$
    this is not the square of anything in $S_6$. A square in $S_6$ has the property that the cycles with a fixed even length appear with an even multiplicity.






    share|cite|improve this answer























    • Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
      – C Monsour
      Nov 16 at 5:36










    • Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
      – C Monsour
      Nov 16 at 5:46








    • 1




      I deleted the erroneous sentence.
      – C Monsour
      Nov 16 at 5:47











    Your Answer





    StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
    return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
    StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
    StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
    });
    });
    }, "mathjax-editing");

    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "69"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    convertImagesToLinks: true,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: 10,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














     

    draft saved


    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2999689%2fhow-to-prove-that-an-even-permutation-of-a-n-is-a-square-of-another-permutatio%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    3 Answers
    3






    active

    oldest

    votes








    3 Answers
    3






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    3
    down vote













    Hint. A permutation is the square of another permutation if and only if, its cycle decomposition has an even number of cycles of length $m$ for every even number $m$.






    share|cite|improve this answer

















    • 1




      Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
      – Jamie Carr
      Nov 15 at 13:19










    • See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
      – Robert Z
      Nov 15 at 17:10















    up vote
    3
    down vote













    Hint. A permutation is the square of another permutation if and only if, its cycle decomposition has an even number of cycles of length $m$ for every even number $m$.






    share|cite|improve this answer

















    • 1




      Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
      – Jamie Carr
      Nov 15 at 13:19










    • See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
      – Robert Z
      Nov 15 at 17:10













    up vote
    3
    down vote










    up vote
    3
    down vote









    Hint. A permutation is the square of another permutation if and only if, its cycle decomposition has an even number of cycles of length $m$ for every even number $m$.






    share|cite|improve this answer












    Hint. A permutation is the square of another permutation if and only if, its cycle decomposition has an even number of cycles of length $m$ for every even number $m$.







    share|cite|improve this answer












    share|cite|improve this answer



    share|cite|improve this answer










    answered Nov 15 at 13:13









    Robert Z

    89.8k1056128




    89.8k1056128








    • 1




      Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
      – Jamie Carr
      Nov 15 at 13:19










    • See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
      – Robert Z
      Nov 15 at 17:10














    • 1




      Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
      – Jamie Carr
      Nov 15 at 13:19










    • See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
      – Robert Z
      Nov 15 at 17:10








    1




    1




    Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
    – Jamie Carr
    Nov 15 at 13:19




    Thanks for your answer but I wonder is there a strict proof of that? I am not so sured that these cycles are distinct so that I can change the order of them to make a perfect square...For example, if p = x^2y^2 does it mean that p is a square of another permutation?
    – Jamie Carr
    Nov 15 at 13:19












    See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
    – Robert Z
    Nov 15 at 17:10




    See for example math.stackexchange.com/questions/266569/…
    – Robert Z
    Nov 15 at 17:10










    up vote
    1
    down vote













    Some more hints:



    Begin by studying the cycle structures of squares $sigma:=picircpi$ of arbitrary permutations. For this it is sufficient to find out what happens to a cycle of odd length under squaring, and what happens to a cycle of even length under squaring.






    share|cite|improve this answer



























      up vote
      1
      down vote













      Some more hints:



      Begin by studying the cycle structures of squares $sigma:=picircpi$ of arbitrary permutations. For this it is sufficient to find out what happens to a cycle of odd length under squaring, and what happens to a cycle of even length under squaring.






      share|cite|improve this answer

























        up vote
        1
        down vote










        up vote
        1
        down vote









        Some more hints:



        Begin by studying the cycle structures of squares $sigma:=picircpi$ of arbitrary permutations. For this it is sufficient to find out what happens to a cycle of odd length under squaring, and what happens to a cycle of even length under squaring.






        share|cite|improve this answer














        Some more hints:



        Begin by studying the cycle structures of squares $sigma:=picircpi$ of arbitrary permutations. For this it is sufficient to find out what happens to a cycle of odd length under squaring, and what happens to a cycle of even length under squaring.







        share|cite|improve this answer














        share|cite|improve this answer



        share|cite|improve this answer








        edited Nov 15 at 15:37

























        answered Nov 15 at 13:34









        Christian Blatter

        170k7111324




        170k7111324






















            up vote
            1
            down vote













            That's not remotely true: the density of squares in $S_n$ goes to zero as $nto +infty$ (like $frac{C}{sqrt{n}}$, actually), while your claim would imply that the $liminf$ of such density is at least $frac{1}{2}$. Indeed, if we consider
            $$sigma = (1,2)(3,4,5,6) in A_6 $$
            this is not the square of anything in $S_6$. A square in $S_6$ has the property that the cycles with a fixed even length appear with an even multiplicity.






            share|cite|improve this answer























            • Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:36










            • Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:46








            • 1




              I deleted the erroneous sentence.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:47















            up vote
            1
            down vote













            That's not remotely true: the density of squares in $S_n$ goes to zero as $nto +infty$ (like $frac{C}{sqrt{n}}$, actually), while your claim would imply that the $liminf$ of such density is at least $frac{1}{2}$. Indeed, if we consider
            $$sigma = (1,2)(3,4,5,6) in A_6 $$
            this is not the square of anything in $S_6$. A square in $S_6$ has the property that the cycles with a fixed even length appear with an even multiplicity.






            share|cite|improve this answer























            • Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:36










            • Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:46








            • 1




              I deleted the erroneous sentence.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:47













            up vote
            1
            down vote










            up vote
            1
            down vote









            That's not remotely true: the density of squares in $S_n$ goes to zero as $nto +infty$ (like $frac{C}{sqrt{n}}$, actually), while your claim would imply that the $liminf$ of such density is at least $frac{1}{2}$. Indeed, if we consider
            $$sigma = (1,2)(3,4,5,6) in A_6 $$
            this is not the square of anything in $S_6$. A square in $S_6$ has the property that the cycles with a fixed even length appear with an even multiplicity.






            share|cite|improve this answer














            That's not remotely true: the density of squares in $S_n$ goes to zero as $nto +infty$ (like $frac{C}{sqrt{n}}$, actually), while your claim would imply that the $liminf$ of such density is at least $frac{1}{2}$. Indeed, if we consider
            $$sigma = (1,2)(3,4,5,6) in A_6 $$
            this is not the square of anything in $S_6$. A square in $S_6$ has the property that the cycles with a fixed even length appear with an even multiplicity.







            share|cite|improve this answer














            share|cite|improve this answer



            share|cite|improve this answer








            edited Nov 16 at 5:47









            C Monsour

            5,552224




            5,552224










            answered Nov 15 at 18:32









            Jack D'Aurizio

            282k33274653




            282k33274653












            • Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:36










            • Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:46








            • 1




              I deleted the erroneous sentence.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:47


















            • Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:36










            • Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:46








            • 1




              I deleted the erroneous sentence.
              – C Monsour
              Nov 16 at 5:47
















            Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
            – C Monsour
            Nov 16 at 5:36




            Your last sentence is completely false. For example the set of squares in any dihedral group form a subgroup, and the set of squares in $S_5$ are in fact $A_5$.
            – C Monsour
            Nov 16 at 5:36












            Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
            – C Monsour
            Nov 16 at 5:46






            Not to mention that the squares form a subgroup of any group of odd order.
            – C Monsour
            Nov 16 at 5:46






            1




            1




            I deleted the erroneous sentence.
            – C Monsour
            Nov 16 at 5:47




            I deleted the erroneous sentence.
            – C Monsour
            Nov 16 at 5:47


















             

            draft saved


            draft discarded



















































             


            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f2999689%2fhow-to-prove-that-an-even-permutation-of-a-n-is-a-square-of-another-permutatio%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Quarter-circle Tiles

            build a pushdown automaton that recognizes the reverse language of a given pushdown automaton?

            Mont Emei