Short Story about being unable to understand aliens











up vote
14
down vote

favorite
4












Some time ago I read a short story about humans' inability to understand alien culture/society.



The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed, and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story. This is where the details get hazy. The title of the short story might have had some sort of action in it, like dance, or flight or something like it, and I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis. Sorry about the low details here.



When the story ends, the human is still unable to understand why the workers were killed, and I don't remember how exactly it ended. If anyone can find it, I applaud you.










share|improve this question







New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
















  • 6




    Sounds like book two of the Ender series by Orson Scott Card, Speaker for the Dead. A small colony is established to support scientists who can't work out why the aliens keep murdering people. It turns out that for aliens this isn't a permanent death
    – Valorum
    13 hours ago










  • A couple of answers have been posted. If one of the posted answers has the story you were looking for, you can "accept" the answer of your choice by clicking on the check mark next to it.
    – user14111
    1 hour ago















up vote
14
down vote

favorite
4












Some time ago I read a short story about humans' inability to understand alien culture/society.



The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed, and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story. This is where the details get hazy. The title of the short story might have had some sort of action in it, like dance, or flight or something like it, and I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis. Sorry about the low details here.



When the story ends, the human is still unable to understand why the workers were killed, and I don't remember how exactly it ended. If anyone can find it, I applaud you.










share|improve this question







New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
















  • 6




    Sounds like book two of the Ender series by Orson Scott Card, Speaker for the Dead. A small colony is established to support scientists who can't work out why the aliens keep murdering people. It turns out that for aliens this isn't a permanent death
    – Valorum
    13 hours ago










  • A couple of answers have been posted. If one of the posted answers has the story you were looking for, you can "accept" the answer of your choice by clicking on the check mark next to it.
    – user14111
    1 hour ago













up vote
14
down vote

favorite
4









up vote
14
down vote

favorite
4






4





Some time ago I read a short story about humans' inability to understand alien culture/society.



The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed, and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story. This is where the details get hazy. The title of the short story might have had some sort of action in it, like dance, or flight or something like it, and I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis. Sorry about the low details here.



When the story ends, the human is still unable to understand why the workers were killed, and I don't remember how exactly it ended. If anyone can find it, I applaud you.










share|improve this question







New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.











Some time ago I read a short story about humans' inability to understand alien culture/society.



The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed, and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story. This is where the details get hazy. The title of the short story might have had some sort of action in it, like dance, or flight or something like it, and I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis. Sorry about the low details here.



When the story ends, the human is still unable to understand why the workers were killed, and I don't remember how exactly it ended. If anyone can find it, I applaud you.







story-identification short-stories aliens






share|improve this question







New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.











share|improve this question







New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









share|improve this question




share|improve this question






New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









asked 14 hours ago









Stian Grønlund

713




713




New contributor




Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.





New contributor





Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






Stian Grønlund is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.








  • 6




    Sounds like book two of the Ender series by Orson Scott Card, Speaker for the Dead. A small colony is established to support scientists who can't work out why the aliens keep murdering people. It turns out that for aliens this isn't a permanent death
    – Valorum
    13 hours ago










  • A couple of answers have been posted. If one of the posted answers has the story you were looking for, you can "accept" the answer of your choice by clicking on the check mark next to it.
    – user14111
    1 hour ago














  • 6




    Sounds like book two of the Ender series by Orson Scott Card, Speaker for the Dead. A small colony is established to support scientists who can't work out why the aliens keep murdering people. It turns out that for aliens this isn't a permanent death
    – Valorum
    13 hours ago










  • A couple of answers have been posted. If one of the posted answers has the story you were looking for, you can "accept" the answer of your choice by clicking on the check mark next to it.
    – user14111
    1 hour ago








6




6




Sounds like book two of the Ender series by Orson Scott Card, Speaker for the Dead. A small colony is established to support scientists who can't work out why the aliens keep murdering people. It turns out that for aliens this isn't a permanent death
– Valorum
13 hours ago




Sounds like book two of the Ender series by Orson Scott Card, Speaker for the Dead. A small colony is established to support scientists who can't work out why the aliens keep murdering people. It turns out that for aliens this isn't a permanent death
– Valorum
13 hours ago












A couple of answers have been posted. If one of the posted answers has the story you were looking for, you can "accept" the answer of your choice by clicking on the check mark next to it.
– user14111
1 hour ago




A couple of answers have been posted. If one of the posted answers has the story you were looking for, you can "accept" the answer of your choice by clicking on the check mark next to it.
– user14111
1 hour ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
21
down vote













"The Dance of the Changer and the Three", a short story by Terry Carr, first published in the 1968 original-stories anthology The Farthest Reaches edited by Joseph Elder; the reprint in Vertex, April 1973 is available at the Internet Archive. Does any of these covers ring a bell?



The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed,




After we'd been on the planet for four Standard Years, after we'd established contact and exchanged gifts and favors and information with the Loarra, after we'd set up our entire mining operation and had had it running without hindrance for over three years—after all that, the raid came. One day a sheet of dull purple light swept in from the horizon, and as it got closer I could see that it was a whole colony of the Loarra, their individual colors and fluctuations blending into that single purple mass. I was in the mountain, not outside with the mining extensors, so I saw all of it, and I lived through it.

They flashed in over us like locusts descending, and they hit the crawlers and dredges first. The metal glowed red, then white, then it melted. Then it was just gas that formed billowing clouds rising to the sky. Somewhere inside those clouds was what was left of the elements which had comprised seventeen human beings, who were also vapor now.




and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



Not exactly. The narrator, having survived the attack, tries to get an explanation from the natives:




I sent out a sequence of lights and movements that translated, roughly, as "What the hell did you do that for?"

And Pur glowed pale yellow for several seconds, then gave me an answer that doesn't translate. Or, if it does, the translation is just, "Because."

Then I asked the question again, in different terms, and she gave me the same answer in different terms. I asked a third time, and a fourth, and she came back with the same thing. She seemed to be enjoying the variations on the dance; maybe she thought we were playing.

Well . . . We'd already sent our distress call by then, so all we could do was wait for a relief ship and hope they wouldn't attack again before the ship came, because we didn't have a chance of fighting them—we were miners, not a military expedition. God knows what a military expedition could have done against energy things, anyway. While we were waiting, I kept sending out the "eyes," and I kept talking to one Loarra after another. It took three weeks for the ship to get there, and I must have talked to over a hundred of them in that time, and the sum total of what I was told was this:

Their reason for wiping out the mining operation was untranslatable. No, they weren't mad. No, they didn't want us to go away. Yes, we were welcome to the stuff we were taking out of the depths of the Loarran ocean.

And, most important, they couldn't tell me whether or not they were likely ever to repeat their attack.




The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story.




This all happened ages ago, and in the depths of space beyond Darkedge, where galaxies lumber ponderously through the black like so many silent bright rhinoceroses. It was so long ago that when the light from Loarr's galaxy finally reached Earth, after millions of light-years, there was no one here to see it except a few things in the oceans that were too mindlessly busy with their monotonous single-celled reactions to notice.

Yet, as long ago as it was, the present-day Loarra still remember this story and retell it in complex, shifting wave-dances every time one of the newly changed asks for it. [. . .] In fact, you could take this as a piece of pure fiction, because there are damned few real facts in it—but I know better (or worse), because I know how true it is. And that has a lot to do with why I'm back here on Earth, with forty-two friends and co-workers left dead on Loarr. They never had a chance.


There was a Changer who had spent three life cycles planning a particular cycleclimax and who had come to the moment of action. He wasn't really named Minnearo, but I'll call him that because it's the closest thing I can write to approximate the tone, emotional matrix, and association that were all wrapped up in his designation.

When he came to his decision, he turned away from the crag on which he'd been standing overlooking the Loarran ocean, and went quickly to the personality-homes of three of his best friends. To the first friend, Asterrea, he said, "I am going to commit suicide," wave-dancing this message in his best festive tone.

His friend laughed, as Minnearo had hoped, but only for a short time. Then he turned away and left Minnearo alone, because there had already been several suicides lately, and it was wearing a little thin.




I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis.



They meet the Oldest:




When the Oldest had told them what they wanted to know, the Three came alive with popping and flashing and dancing in the air, Pur just as much as the others. It was all that they had hoped for and more; it was the entire answer to their quest and their problem. It would enable them to create, to transcend any negative cycle-climax they could have devised.







share|improve this answer






























    up vote
    3
    down vote













    This sounds like the premise for Speaker For the Dead, the second book in the Ender's Game series by Orson Scott Card.



    According to Wikipedia's synopsis:




    ...a human colony is established on the planet Lusitania. The planet is
    home to a sentient species of mammalian forest dwellers called "Pequeninos"




    One of the only humans to have contact with the alien species is found killed:




    Xenologer Pipo has developed a friendship with the Pequeninos...
    Pipo finds one of the males dead, his body eviscerated
    and a sapling planted within the body, believing this to be their
    funeral rites... Pipo's body is later found cut open.




    Ender (from the first book in the series, Ender's Game) is called to come investigate. He eventually finds




    [They] help Ender to corroborate the complex life cycle
    of the Pequeninos, affirming that the death ritual Pipo observed was
    to help create "fathertrees" who fertilize the Pequenino females to
    continue their race. The Pequeninos believed they were honoring Pipo...







    share|improve this answer








    New contributor




    jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
    Check out our Code of Conduct.


















      Your Answer








      StackExchange.ready(function() {
      var channelOptions = {
      tags: "".split(" "),
      id: "186"
      };
      initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

      StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
      // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
      if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
      StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
      createEditor();
      });
      }
      else {
      createEditor();
      }
      });

      function createEditor() {
      StackExchange.prepareEditor({
      heartbeatType: 'answer',
      convertImagesToLinks: false,
      noModals: true,
      showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
      reputationToPostImages: null,
      bindNavPrevention: true,
      postfix: "",
      imageUploader: {
      brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
      contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
      allowUrls: true
      },
      noCode: true, onDemand: true,
      discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
      ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
      });


      }
      });






      Stian Grønlund is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.










      draft saved

      draft discarded


















      StackExchange.ready(
      function () {
      StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f200299%2fshort-story-about-being-unable-to-understand-aliens%23new-answer', 'question_page');
      }
      );

      Post as a guest















      Required, but never shown

























      2 Answers
      2






      active

      oldest

      votes








      2 Answers
      2






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes








      up vote
      21
      down vote













      "The Dance of the Changer and the Three", a short story by Terry Carr, first published in the 1968 original-stories anthology The Farthest Reaches edited by Joseph Elder; the reprint in Vertex, April 1973 is available at the Internet Archive. Does any of these covers ring a bell?



      The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed,




      After we'd been on the planet for four Standard Years, after we'd established contact and exchanged gifts and favors and information with the Loarra, after we'd set up our entire mining operation and had had it running without hindrance for over three years—after all that, the raid came. One day a sheet of dull purple light swept in from the horizon, and as it got closer I could see that it was a whole colony of the Loarra, their individual colors and fluctuations blending into that single purple mass. I was in the mountain, not outside with the mining extensors, so I saw all of it, and I lived through it.

      They flashed in over us like locusts descending, and they hit the crawlers and dredges first. The metal glowed red, then white, then it melted. Then it was just gas that formed billowing clouds rising to the sky. Somewhere inside those clouds was what was left of the elements which had comprised seventeen human beings, who were also vapor now.




      and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



      Not exactly. The narrator, having survived the attack, tries to get an explanation from the natives:




      I sent out a sequence of lights and movements that translated, roughly, as "What the hell did you do that for?"

      And Pur glowed pale yellow for several seconds, then gave me an answer that doesn't translate. Or, if it does, the translation is just, "Because."

      Then I asked the question again, in different terms, and she gave me the same answer in different terms. I asked a third time, and a fourth, and she came back with the same thing. She seemed to be enjoying the variations on the dance; maybe she thought we were playing.

      Well . . . We'd already sent our distress call by then, so all we could do was wait for a relief ship and hope they wouldn't attack again before the ship came, because we didn't have a chance of fighting them—we were miners, not a military expedition. God knows what a military expedition could have done against energy things, anyway. While we were waiting, I kept sending out the "eyes," and I kept talking to one Loarra after another. It took three weeks for the ship to get there, and I must have talked to over a hundred of them in that time, and the sum total of what I was told was this:

      Their reason for wiping out the mining operation was untranslatable. No, they weren't mad. No, they didn't want us to go away. Yes, we were welcome to the stuff we were taking out of the depths of the Loarran ocean.

      And, most important, they couldn't tell me whether or not they were likely ever to repeat their attack.




      The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story.




      This all happened ages ago, and in the depths of space beyond Darkedge, where galaxies lumber ponderously through the black like so many silent bright rhinoceroses. It was so long ago that when the light from Loarr's galaxy finally reached Earth, after millions of light-years, there was no one here to see it except a few things in the oceans that were too mindlessly busy with their monotonous single-celled reactions to notice.

      Yet, as long ago as it was, the present-day Loarra still remember this story and retell it in complex, shifting wave-dances every time one of the newly changed asks for it. [. . .] In fact, you could take this as a piece of pure fiction, because there are damned few real facts in it—but I know better (or worse), because I know how true it is. And that has a lot to do with why I'm back here on Earth, with forty-two friends and co-workers left dead on Loarr. They never had a chance.


      There was a Changer who had spent three life cycles planning a particular cycleclimax and who had come to the moment of action. He wasn't really named Minnearo, but I'll call him that because it's the closest thing I can write to approximate the tone, emotional matrix, and association that were all wrapped up in his designation.

      When he came to his decision, he turned away from the crag on which he'd been standing overlooking the Loarran ocean, and went quickly to the personality-homes of three of his best friends. To the first friend, Asterrea, he said, "I am going to commit suicide," wave-dancing this message in his best festive tone.

      His friend laughed, as Minnearo had hoped, but only for a short time. Then he turned away and left Minnearo alone, because there had already been several suicides lately, and it was wearing a little thin.




      I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis.



      They meet the Oldest:




      When the Oldest had told them what they wanted to know, the Three came alive with popping and flashing and dancing in the air, Pur just as much as the others. It was all that they had hoped for and more; it was the entire answer to their quest and their problem. It would enable them to create, to transcend any negative cycle-climax they could have devised.







      share|improve this answer



























        up vote
        21
        down vote













        "The Dance of the Changer and the Three", a short story by Terry Carr, first published in the 1968 original-stories anthology The Farthest Reaches edited by Joseph Elder; the reprint in Vertex, April 1973 is available at the Internet Archive. Does any of these covers ring a bell?



        The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed,




        After we'd been on the planet for four Standard Years, after we'd established contact and exchanged gifts and favors and information with the Loarra, after we'd set up our entire mining operation and had had it running without hindrance for over three years—after all that, the raid came. One day a sheet of dull purple light swept in from the horizon, and as it got closer I could see that it was a whole colony of the Loarra, their individual colors and fluctuations blending into that single purple mass. I was in the mountain, not outside with the mining extensors, so I saw all of it, and I lived through it.

        They flashed in over us like locusts descending, and they hit the crawlers and dredges first. The metal glowed red, then white, then it melted. Then it was just gas that formed billowing clouds rising to the sky. Somewhere inside those clouds was what was left of the elements which had comprised seventeen human beings, who were also vapor now.




        and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



        Not exactly. The narrator, having survived the attack, tries to get an explanation from the natives:




        I sent out a sequence of lights and movements that translated, roughly, as "What the hell did you do that for?"

        And Pur glowed pale yellow for several seconds, then gave me an answer that doesn't translate. Or, if it does, the translation is just, "Because."

        Then I asked the question again, in different terms, and she gave me the same answer in different terms. I asked a third time, and a fourth, and she came back with the same thing. She seemed to be enjoying the variations on the dance; maybe she thought we were playing.

        Well . . . We'd already sent our distress call by then, so all we could do was wait for a relief ship and hope they wouldn't attack again before the ship came, because we didn't have a chance of fighting them—we were miners, not a military expedition. God knows what a military expedition could have done against energy things, anyway. While we were waiting, I kept sending out the "eyes," and I kept talking to one Loarra after another. It took three weeks for the ship to get there, and I must have talked to over a hundred of them in that time, and the sum total of what I was told was this:

        Their reason for wiping out the mining operation was untranslatable. No, they weren't mad. No, they didn't want us to go away. Yes, we were welcome to the stuff we were taking out of the depths of the Loarran ocean.

        And, most important, they couldn't tell me whether or not they were likely ever to repeat their attack.




        The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story.




        This all happened ages ago, and in the depths of space beyond Darkedge, where galaxies lumber ponderously through the black like so many silent bright rhinoceroses. It was so long ago that when the light from Loarr's galaxy finally reached Earth, after millions of light-years, there was no one here to see it except a few things in the oceans that were too mindlessly busy with their monotonous single-celled reactions to notice.

        Yet, as long ago as it was, the present-day Loarra still remember this story and retell it in complex, shifting wave-dances every time one of the newly changed asks for it. [. . .] In fact, you could take this as a piece of pure fiction, because there are damned few real facts in it—but I know better (or worse), because I know how true it is. And that has a lot to do with why I'm back here on Earth, with forty-two friends and co-workers left dead on Loarr. They never had a chance.


        There was a Changer who had spent three life cycles planning a particular cycleclimax and who had come to the moment of action. He wasn't really named Minnearo, but I'll call him that because it's the closest thing I can write to approximate the tone, emotional matrix, and association that were all wrapped up in his designation.

        When he came to his decision, he turned away from the crag on which he'd been standing overlooking the Loarran ocean, and went quickly to the personality-homes of three of his best friends. To the first friend, Asterrea, he said, "I am going to commit suicide," wave-dancing this message in his best festive tone.

        His friend laughed, as Minnearo had hoped, but only for a short time. Then he turned away and left Minnearo alone, because there had already been several suicides lately, and it was wearing a little thin.




        I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis.



        They meet the Oldest:




        When the Oldest had told them what they wanted to know, the Three came alive with popping and flashing and dancing in the air, Pur just as much as the others. It was all that they had hoped for and more; it was the entire answer to their quest and their problem. It would enable them to create, to transcend any negative cycle-climax they could have devised.







        share|improve this answer

























          up vote
          21
          down vote










          up vote
          21
          down vote









          "The Dance of the Changer and the Three", a short story by Terry Carr, first published in the 1968 original-stories anthology The Farthest Reaches edited by Joseph Elder; the reprint in Vertex, April 1973 is available at the Internet Archive. Does any of these covers ring a bell?



          The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed,




          After we'd been on the planet for four Standard Years, after we'd established contact and exchanged gifts and favors and information with the Loarra, after we'd set up our entire mining operation and had had it running without hindrance for over three years—after all that, the raid came. One day a sheet of dull purple light swept in from the horizon, and as it got closer I could see that it was a whole colony of the Loarra, their individual colors and fluctuations blending into that single purple mass. I was in the mountain, not outside with the mining extensors, so I saw all of it, and I lived through it.

          They flashed in over us like locusts descending, and they hit the crawlers and dredges first. The metal glowed red, then white, then it melted. Then it was just gas that formed billowing clouds rising to the sky. Somewhere inside those clouds was what was left of the elements which had comprised seventeen human beings, who were also vapor now.




          and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



          Not exactly. The narrator, having survived the attack, tries to get an explanation from the natives:




          I sent out a sequence of lights and movements that translated, roughly, as "What the hell did you do that for?"

          And Pur glowed pale yellow for several seconds, then gave me an answer that doesn't translate. Or, if it does, the translation is just, "Because."

          Then I asked the question again, in different terms, and she gave me the same answer in different terms. I asked a third time, and a fourth, and she came back with the same thing. She seemed to be enjoying the variations on the dance; maybe she thought we were playing.

          Well . . . We'd already sent our distress call by then, so all we could do was wait for a relief ship and hope they wouldn't attack again before the ship came, because we didn't have a chance of fighting them—we were miners, not a military expedition. God knows what a military expedition could have done against energy things, anyway. While we were waiting, I kept sending out the "eyes," and I kept talking to one Loarra after another. It took three weeks for the ship to get there, and I must have talked to over a hundred of them in that time, and the sum total of what I was told was this:

          Their reason for wiping out the mining operation was untranslatable. No, they weren't mad. No, they didn't want us to go away. Yes, we were welcome to the stuff we were taking out of the depths of the Loarran ocean.

          And, most important, they couldn't tell me whether or not they were likely ever to repeat their attack.




          The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story.




          This all happened ages ago, and in the depths of space beyond Darkedge, where galaxies lumber ponderously through the black like so many silent bright rhinoceroses. It was so long ago that when the light from Loarr's galaxy finally reached Earth, after millions of light-years, there was no one here to see it except a few things in the oceans that were too mindlessly busy with their monotonous single-celled reactions to notice.

          Yet, as long ago as it was, the present-day Loarra still remember this story and retell it in complex, shifting wave-dances every time one of the newly changed asks for it. [. . .] In fact, you could take this as a piece of pure fiction, because there are damned few real facts in it—but I know better (or worse), because I know how true it is. And that has a lot to do with why I'm back here on Earth, with forty-two friends and co-workers left dead on Loarr. They never had a chance.


          There was a Changer who had spent three life cycles planning a particular cycleclimax and who had come to the moment of action. He wasn't really named Minnearo, but I'll call him that because it's the closest thing I can write to approximate the tone, emotional matrix, and association that were all wrapped up in his designation.

          When he came to his decision, he turned away from the crag on which he'd been standing overlooking the Loarran ocean, and went quickly to the personality-homes of three of his best friends. To the first friend, Asterrea, he said, "I am going to commit suicide," wave-dancing this message in his best festive tone.

          His friend laughed, as Minnearo had hoped, but only for a short time. Then he turned away and left Minnearo alone, because there had already been several suicides lately, and it was wearing a little thin.




          I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis.



          They meet the Oldest:




          When the Oldest had told them what they wanted to know, the Three came alive with popping and flashing and dancing in the air, Pur just as much as the others. It was all that they had hoped for and more; it was the entire answer to their quest and their problem. It would enable them to create, to transcend any negative cycle-climax they could have devised.







          share|improve this answer














          "The Dance of the Changer and the Three", a short story by Terry Carr, first published in the 1968 original-stories anthology The Farthest Reaches edited by Joseph Elder; the reprint in Vertex, April 1973 is available at the Internet Archive. Does any of these covers ring a bell?



          The premise was that we had a colony of sorts on an alien planet, that was comprised of a team of workers. These workers were killed,




          After we'd been on the planet for four Standard Years, after we'd established contact and exchanged gifts and favors and information with the Loarra, after we'd set up our entire mining operation and had had it running without hindrance for over three years—after all that, the raid came. One day a sheet of dull purple light swept in from the horizon, and as it got closer I could see that it was a whole colony of the Loarra, their individual colors and fluctuations blending into that single purple mass. I was in the mountain, not outside with the mining extensors, so I saw all of it, and I lived through it.

          They flashed in over us like locusts descending, and they hit the crawlers and dredges first. The metal glowed red, then white, then it melted. Then it was just gas that formed billowing clouds rising to the sky. Somewhere inside those clouds was what was left of the elements which had comprised seventeen human beings, who were also vapor now.




          and someone was sent to the planet to understand why these workers were killed.



          Not exactly. The narrator, having survived the attack, tries to get an explanation from the natives:




          I sent out a sequence of lights and movements that translated, roughly, as "What the hell did you do that for?"

          And Pur glowed pale yellow for several seconds, then gave me an answer that doesn't translate. Or, if it does, the translation is just, "Because."

          Then I asked the question again, in different terms, and she gave me the same answer in different terms. I asked a third time, and a fourth, and she came back with the same thing. She seemed to be enjoying the variations on the dance; maybe she thought we were playing.

          Well . . . We'd already sent our distress call by then, so all we could do was wait for a relief ship and hope they wouldn't attack again before the ship came, because we didn't have a chance of fighting them—we were miners, not a military expedition. God knows what a military expedition could have done against energy things, anyway. While we were waiting, I kept sending out the "eyes," and I kept talking to one Loarra after another. It took three weeks for the ship to get there, and I must have talked to over a hundred of them in that time, and the sum total of what I was told was this:

          Their reason for wiping out the mining operation was untranslatable. No, they weren't mad. No, they didn't want us to go away. Yes, we were welcome to the stuff we were taking out of the depths of the Loarran ocean.

          And, most important, they couldn't tell me whether or not they were likely ever to repeat their attack.




          The aliens then proceeded to tell a story, in order to explain to this human their culture and why these workers had to be killed. The name of this story/myth was also the name of the short story.




          This all happened ages ago, and in the depths of space beyond Darkedge, where galaxies lumber ponderously through the black like so many silent bright rhinoceroses. It was so long ago that when the light from Loarr's galaxy finally reached Earth, after millions of light-years, there was no one here to see it except a few things in the oceans that were too mindlessly busy with their monotonous single-celled reactions to notice.

          Yet, as long ago as it was, the present-day Loarra still remember this story and retell it in complex, shifting wave-dances every time one of the newly changed asks for it. [. . .] In fact, you could take this as a piece of pure fiction, because there are damned few real facts in it—but I know better (or worse), because I know how true it is. And that has a lot to do with why I'm back here on Earth, with forty-two friends and co-workers left dead on Loarr. They never had a chance.


          There was a Changer who had spent three life cycles planning a particular cycleclimax and who had come to the moment of action. He wasn't really named Minnearo, but I'll call him that because it's the closest thing I can write to approximate the tone, emotional matrix, and association that were all wrapped up in his designation.

          When he came to his decision, he turned away from the crag on which he'd been standing overlooking the Loarran ocean, and went quickly to the personality-homes of three of his best friends. To the first friend, Asterrea, he said, "I am going to commit suicide," wave-dancing this message in his best festive tone.

          His friend laughed, as Minnearo had hoped, but only for a short time. Then he turned away and left Minnearo alone, because there had already been several suicides lately, and it was wearing a little thin.




          I think the myth was about three of the aliens making a journey, meeting a fourth, and then undergoing some sort of metamorphosis.



          They meet the Oldest:




          When the Oldest had told them what they wanted to know, the Three came alive with popping and flashing and dancing in the air, Pur just as much as the others. It was all that they had hoped for and more; it was the entire answer to their quest and their problem. It would enable them to create, to transcend any negative cycle-climax they could have devised.








          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited 12 hours ago

























          answered 13 hours ago









          user14111

          98.1k6384493




          98.1k6384493
























              up vote
              3
              down vote













              This sounds like the premise for Speaker For the Dead, the second book in the Ender's Game series by Orson Scott Card.



              According to Wikipedia's synopsis:




              ...a human colony is established on the planet Lusitania. The planet is
              home to a sentient species of mammalian forest dwellers called "Pequeninos"




              One of the only humans to have contact with the alien species is found killed:




              Xenologer Pipo has developed a friendship with the Pequeninos...
              Pipo finds one of the males dead, his body eviscerated
              and a sapling planted within the body, believing this to be their
              funeral rites... Pipo's body is later found cut open.




              Ender (from the first book in the series, Ender's Game) is called to come investigate. He eventually finds




              [They] help Ender to corroborate the complex life cycle
              of the Pequeninos, affirming that the death ritual Pipo observed was
              to help create "fathertrees" who fertilize the Pequenino females to
              continue their race. The Pequeninos believed they were honoring Pipo...







              share|improve this answer








              New contributor




              jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
              Check out our Code of Conduct.






















                up vote
                3
                down vote













                This sounds like the premise for Speaker For the Dead, the second book in the Ender's Game series by Orson Scott Card.



                According to Wikipedia's synopsis:




                ...a human colony is established on the planet Lusitania. The planet is
                home to a sentient species of mammalian forest dwellers called "Pequeninos"




                One of the only humans to have contact with the alien species is found killed:




                Xenologer Pipo has developed a friendship with the Pequeninos...
                Pipo finds one of the males dead, his body eviscerated
                and a sapling planted within the body, believing this to be their
                funeral rites... Pipo's body is later found cut open.




                Ender (from the first book in the series, Ender's Game) is called to come investigate. He eventually finds




                [They] help Ender to corroborate the complex life cycle
                of the Pequeninos, affirming that the death ritual Pipo observed was
                to help create "fathertrees" who fertilize the Pequenino females to
                continue their race. The Pequeninos believed they were honoring Pipo...







                share|improve this answer








                New contributor




                jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.




















                  up vote
                  3
                  down vote










                  up vote
                  3
                  down vote









                  This sounds like the premise for Speaker For the Dead, the second book in the Ender's Game series by Orson Scott Card.



                  According to Wikipedia's synopsis:




                  ...a human colony is established on the planet Lusitania. The planet is
                  home to a sentient species of mammalian forest dwellers called "Pequeninos"




                  One of the only humans to have contact with the alien species is found killed:




                  Xenologer Pipo has developed a friendship with the Pequeninos...
                  Pipo finds one of the males dead, his body eviscerated
                  and a sapling planted within the body, believing this to be their
                  funeral rites... Pipo's body is later found cut open.




                  Ender (from the first book in the series, Ender's Game) is called to come investigate. He eventually finds




                  [They] help Ender to corroborate the complex life cycle
                  of the Pequeninos, affirming that the death ritual Pipo observed was
                  to help create "fathertrees" who fertilize the Pequenino females to
                  continue their race. The Pequeninos believed they were honoring Pipo...







                  share|improve this answer








                  New contributor




                  jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.









                  This sounds like the premise for Speaker For the Dead, the second book in the Ender's Game series by Orson Scott Card.



                  According to Wikipedia's synopsis:




                  ...a human colony is established on the planet Lusitania. The planet is
                  home to a sentient species of mammalian forest dwellers called "Pequeninos"




                  One of the only humans to have contact with the alien species is found killed:




                  Xenologer Pipo has developed a friendship with the Pequeninos...
                  Pipo finds one of the males dead, his body eviscerated
                  and a sapling planted within the body, believing this to be their
                  funeral rites... Pipo's body is later found cut open.




                  Ender (from the first book in the series, Ender's Game) is called to come investigate. He eventually finds




                  [They] help Ender to corroborate the complex life cycle
                  of the Pequeninos, affirming that the death ritual Pipo observed was
                  to help create "fathertrees" who fertilize the Pequenino females to
                  continue their race. The Pequeninos believed they were honoring Pipo...








                  share|improve this answer








                  New contributor




                  jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.









                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer






                  New contributor




                  jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.









                  answered 4 hours ago









                  jekso

                  312




                  312




                  New contributor




                  jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.





                  New contributor





                  jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.






                  jekso is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.






















                      Stian Grønlund is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.










                      draft saved

                      draft discarded


















                      Stian Grønlund is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.













                      Stian Grønlund is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.












                      Stian Grønlund is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
















                      Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!


                      • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                      But avoid



                      • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                      • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                      To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





                      Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


                      Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


                      • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                      But avoid



                      • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                      • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                      To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                      draft saved


                      draft discarded














                      StackExchange.ready(
                      function () {
                      StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f200299%2fshort-story-about-being-unable-to-understand-aliens%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                      }
                      );

                      Post as a guest















                      Required, but never shown





















































                      Required, but never shown














                      Required, but never shown












                      Required, but never shown







                      Required, but never shown

































                      Required, but never shown














                      Required, but never shown












                      Required, but never shown







                      Required, but never shown







                      Popular posts from this blog

                      Mont Emei

                      Province de Neuquén

                      Soliste